FuzzNJ
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:13:00 PM
From Newsweek 2004

"If Bush gets what he wants, the income tax will become a misnomer -- it will really be a salary tax. Almost all income taxes would come from paychecks -- 80 percent of income for most families, less than half for the top 1 percent. Meanwhile taxpayers receiving dividends, interest and capital gains, known collectively as investment income, would have a much lighter burden than salary earners -- or maybe none at all. And here's the topper. In the name of preserving family farms and keeping small businesses in the family, Bush would eliminate the estate tax and create a new class of landed aristocrats who could inherit billions tax-free, invest the money, watch it compound tax-free and hand it down tax-free to their heirs."

"The farther up you go in income level, the more important lower taxes on investment income become. So higher-income people tend to get bigger percentage cuts in their total tax burden from Bush's cuts than lower-income people -- the exact opposite of how a progressive tax system is supposed to work."

HockeyDad
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:16:00 PM
You can cut taxes for people that do not pay taxes. It is called a refundable tax credit.
Kawak
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:19:00 PM
I just saw two videos. One was an Obama campaign ad where he actually had it listed in print on the ad that he would not raise taxes for anyone over 200k. Then right after a video of Biden saying nothing over 150K. 42K here we come!

John McCain accused his Democratic rivals on Tuesday of steadily downgrading their definition of the middle class in an effort to hit more voters with tax increases.

"We can't let that happen," the Republican presidential nominee told a Pennsylvania audience.

Barack Obama has consistently said that families making less than $250,000 a year will not see a tax increase under his administration. He also says those making under $200,000 will see a tax cut.

But Obama's running mate, Joe Biden, told a Scranton, Pa., TV station on Monday that Obama's tax break "should go to middle class people -- people making under $150,000 a year."

McCain, who over the past few days has warned about the "dangerous" economic consequences of allowing a Democrat in the White House to work with a Democratic majority in Congress, said Tuesday that Biden was previewing Democratic tax policies to come.

"You getting an idea of what's on their mind, huh? A little sneak peak," McCain said, pointing to Biden's comment. "It's interesting how their definition of rich has a way of creeping down. At this rate, it won't be long before Senator Obama is right back to his vote that Americans making just $42,000 a year should get a tax increase."

McCain has hammered Obama over his tax policies for the past couple weeks, attempting to make up ground against the Democratic nominee's significant polling lead, nationally and in battleground states, with just one week to go until Election Day. The traditional Gallup daily tracking poll Tuesday, however, showed Obama up just 2 points nationally, after leading by 5 points for the past two days.

FuzzNJ
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:23:00 PM
Kawak, at least post the source of you cut and paste:

http://elections.foxnews.com/2008/10/28/mccain-obamas-definition-rich-creeping/ 

HockeyDad
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:24:00 PM
Pelosi and Reid will let Obama or McCain know exactly what kind of tax cuts they can actually have.
Kawak
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:25:00 PM
#144 Why you'll just deny it. Does it really matter?
FuzzNJ
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:26:00 PM
146: no, it's plagiarism.
beanasdad
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:28:00 PM
141. Author: FuzzNJ

"After the 2003 capital gains tax cut, federal revenues increased in four years by $740 billion. The budget deficit fell from $401 billion in 2004 to $160 billion in 2007. Capital gains revenues increased from $55 billion in 2002 to an estimated $110 billion for 2006. Every indicator shows that the 2003 investment tax cuts helped increase growth, stock market values and federal tax receipts."

http://www.ncpa.org/pub/st/st307/st307f.html 

Hmmmmm, sounds like it worked to me.

Kawak
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:29:00 PM
#147 Exactly. Grape kool-aide?
beanasdad
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:29:00 PM
^ How much of that was contributed to by the lower/middle class?
HockeyDad
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:35:00 PM
^They don't pay tax.
beanasdad
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:39:00 PM
Jeeez, man. Why do you keep pounding that into the ground?

tailgater
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:39:00 PM
Drydog,

Re: 81

What makes you think that I'm in a higher tax bracket than you?

My company is still young and very small.

And we manufacture goods in Massachusetts. Goods that are sold to other manufacturers.

You think I'm doing OK in these times?

You think my customers are on a buying spree?

Do you think that I've been able to pass along even a fraction of the cost increases pushed upon me for materials and transportation??

But maybe you thought I was doing well because you haven't heard me complain about it, or BLAME someone, or EXPECT the GOVERNMENT to fix it for me.

Perhaps you mistook my equitable approach to taxation as a selfish measure rather than as simply a fair and conservative approach supported by history (you can't tax your way out of a recession).

It's likely that you and I are quite similar financially. And it's HIGHLY likely that you were doing much better than I was 5 years ago.

I didn't begrudge you your money then.

Why DEMAND others' money now?

Take some responsibility for yourself.

Don't EXPECT government to do it for you and then demand it from others.

Barack is appeasing the weakest people in America. And fortunately for him, there are MANY that are weak.

He is promissing to "tax the rich" because he knows the rich make up only 1%.

He has repeated this so many times that the WEAK liberals not only believe it is the right thing to do, they believe it is fair.

Even though they don't want to pay more from their own paycheck.

Even though they haven't DEMANDED accountability in our government spending.

To say it's pathetic is a monumental understatement.

FuzzNJ
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:40:00 PM
148:

CBPP RSS Feeds

Areas of Research

Areas of Research

Policy Experts

Policy Experts

Press Room

Press Room

Donate

Donate

About Us

About Us

Jobs

Jobs

Updates

Updates

All Reports by Date

All Reports by Date

Asset Tests

Asset Tests

Climate Change

Climate Change

Earned Income Credit

Earned Income Credit

Economic Stimulus

Economic Stimulus

Federal Budget

Federal Budget

Federal Tax

Federal Tax

Food Assistance

Food Assistance

Health Policies

Health Policies

Housing Policy

Housing Policy

Hurricane Katrina

Hurricane Katrina

Low-Income Immigrants

Low-Income Immigrants

Poverty/Income

Poverty/Income

Program Simplification

Program Simplification

Social Security

Social Security

Special Series

Special Series

State Budget and Tax

State Budget and Tax

Unemployment Insurance

Unemployment Insurance

Welfare Reform/TANF

Welfare Reform/TANF

Press Room Home

Press Room Home

Policy Points

Policy Points

Conference Call Sign Up

Conference Call Sign Up

Policy Points Archive

Policy Points Archive

Background

Background

Staff by Name

Staff by Name

Staff by Department

Staff by Department

Board of Directors

Board of Directors

Employment

Employment

Internships

Internships

RSS Feed

RSS Feed

Email Updates

Email Updates

Policy Points

Revised May 7, 2008

Resources:

pdf PDF (2pp.)

E-mail to a friend

Print

CBPP Services:

E-mail Notifications

RSS Alerts

Related Categories:

All Reports by Date

Federal Tax Policy

EXPERTS AGREE THAT CAPITAL GAINS TAX CUTS LOSE REVENUE

During Wednesday’s Democratic presidential debate, Charles Gibson of ABC News made the following statements about capital gains taxes:

* “Bill Clinton in 1997 signed legislation that dropped the capital gains tax to 20 percent and George Bush has taken it down to 15 percent and in each instance when the rate dropped, revenues from the tax increased. The government took in more money.”

* “So why raise it [the capital gains rate] at all, especially given the fact that 100 million people in this country own stock and would be affected.”

These statements, echoed in a Wall Street Journal editorial today, are seriously misleading, as explained below.

Cutting capital gains rates reduces revenues over the long run. That’s the conclusion of the federal government’s official revenue-estimating agencies, as well as outside experts and the Bush Administration’s own Treasury Department.

* The non-partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) and the Joint Committee on Taxation have estimated that extending the capital gains tax cut enacted in 2003 would cost $100 billion over the next decade. The Administration’s Office of Management and Budget included a similar estimate in the President’s budget.

* After reviewing numerous studies of how investors respond to capital gains tax cuts, CBO commented that “the best estimates of taxpayers’ response to changes in the capital gains rate do not suggest a large revenue increase from additional realizations of capital gains — and certainly not an increase large enough to offset the losses from a lower rate.”

* The Bush Administration Treasury Department examined the economic effects of extending the capital gains and dividend tax cuts. Even under the Treasury’s most optimistic scenario about the economic effects of these tax cuts, the tax cuts would not generate anywhere close to enough added economic growth to pay for themselves — and would thus lose money.

While a capital gains tax cut can lead investors to rush to “cash in” their capital gains when the lower rate first takes effect, it does not raise revenue over the long run.

* Especially when a capital gains cut is temporary, like the 2003 tax cut that Gibson cited, investors have a strong incentive to sell stocks and other assets in order to realize their capital gains before the capital gains tax rate increases. This can cause a short-term increase in capital gains tax revenues, as happened after the 2003 tax cut.

* Capital gains revenues also increased after 2003 because the stock market went up. But the stock market increase was not a result of the 2003 tax cut, as a study by Federal Reserve economists found. European stocks, which did not benefit from the U.S. capital gains tax cut, performed as well as stocks in the U.S. market in the period following the tax cut.

* To raise revenue over the long run, capital gains tax cuts would need to have extraordinary huge, positive effects on saving, investment, and economic growth that virtually no respected expert or institution believes they have. In fact, experts are not even sure that the long-term economic effects of these capital gains tax cuts are positive rather then negative.

One reason is that preferential tax rates for capital gains encourage tax sheltering, by creating incentives for taxpayers to take often-convoluted steps to reclassify ordinary income as capital gains. This is economically unproductive and wastes resources. The Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center’s director Leonard Burman, one of the nation’s leading tax experts, has explained, “shelter investments are invariably lousy, unproductive ventures that would never exist but for tax benefits.” Burman has concluded that, “capital gains tax cuts are as likely to depress the economy as to stimulate it.”

Middle-income families derive only a miniscule benefit from the 2003 cuts in capital gains and dividends.

Charles Gibson’s second statement — that 100 million Americans own stock and would be affected by a change in the capital gains tax rate — also is mistaken.

* Most middle-income Americans own much or all of their stock through 401(k)s, IRAs, or other tax-preferred saving accounts. They do not pay taxes when their stocks within those accounts go up, so a change in the tax rate doesn’t affect them.

Even among the minority of middle-class Americans who do benefit from the capital gains and dividend tax cuts, the benefits are very small. This is because capital gains and dividend income is highly concentrated at the very top of the income scale. The Tax Policy Center estimates that the highest-income 5 percent of U.S. households receive 83 percent of total capital gains income.

* According to the Tax Policy Center, the average household in the middle of the income spectrum received $20 from the 2003 capital gains and dividend tax cuts. The average household earning over $1 million received $32,000, or 1,600 times as much.

The myth that tax cuts pay for themselves hinders a debate on the nation’s budget priorities — and its serious long-term budget problems and the tough choices we must make to address them — by creating the illusion of a free lunch. Such free lunches do not exist. Capital gains tax cuts either make the nation’s daunting long-term budget problems even more severe or consume scarce resources (primarily to the benefit of the most well-off) that could otherwise be used for purposes such as moving toward universal health coverage or improving the educational system.

*

Even among the minority of middle-class Americans who do benefit from the capital gains and dividend tax cuts, the benefits are very small. This is because capital gains and dividend income is highly concentrated at the very top of the income scale. The Tax Policy Center estimates that the highest-income 5 percent of U.S. households receive 83 percent of total capital gains income.

* According to the Tax Policy Center, the average household in the middle of the income spectrum received $20 from the 2003 capital gains and dividend tax cuts. The average household earning over $1 million received $32,000, or 1,600 times as much.

The myth that tax cuts pay for themselves hinders a debate on the nation’s budget priorities — and its serious long-term budget problems and the tough choices we must make to address them — by creating the illusion of a free lunch. Such free lunches do not exist. Capital gains tax cuts either make the nation’s daunting long-term budget problems even more severe or consume scarce resources (primarily to the benefit of the most well-off) that could otherwise be used for purposes such as moving toward universal health coverage or improving the educational system.

http://www.cbpp.org/policy-points4-18-08.htm 

FuzzNJ
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:40:00 PM
149: Mmmmm, grape.
MACS
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:42:00 PM
It's SO easy to give money to the less fortunate.

Especially when the money isn't yours!!!

Who cares if those "less fortunate" have the ability to improve their station... if we take the money from the rich, they won't HAVE to!!!

beanasdad
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 6:55:00 PM
154. Author: FuzzNJ

Yeah, I can see where you're going w/ this:

"Even Bush's Treasury Dept. says that cuts in capitol gains tax reduces revenue in the long run."

Well, in the past, raising it hasn't help much either:

"In 1986, the tax rate increased by 40 percent, from 20 to 28 percent. Did tax revenues climb by 40 percent? Just the opposite occurred. In 1990, the federal government took in 13 percent less revenue at the 28 percent rate than it did in 1985 at the 20 percent rate. In 1991 (and again in 1992), the government collected more than 15 percent less revenue than it did in 1985."

However:

"In 1996, the year before the capital gains tax rate was cut from 28 to 20 percent, net capital gains on assets sold were roughly $335 billion. A year later, capital gains had leapt to $459 billion. (The tax cut was retroactive to May 1997.) In 1996 the Treasury collected roughly $85 billion in capital gains revenues. In 1997 those tax payments soared to $100 billion."

Now, show me in hard #'s where cutting the capitol gains tax decreases revenue, and quit showing me what ppl "think" will happen.

FuzzNJ
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 7:03:00 PM
"Now, show me in hard #'s where cutting the capitol gains tax decreases revenue, and quit showing me what ppl "think" will happen."

Okay, now that is funny right there considering the predictions posted on this board of what will happen after an Obama win next Tuesday.

beanasdad
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 7:05:00 PM

My statement/question stands.