I'm curious as to what people like in this size cigar. I like the Camacho SLR and AF SS.

Hoyo Maddie or Oscuro

RyJ Tubo

CAO Anni Cammie

I have always wondered about the CAO Anniv Cammie - what is the flavor profile on them? Thanks!

really, really good. seriously, i really like this cigar. i'm not good at describing flavors. to me, there's really good, pretty good, not so good, and nasty insoles rolled in sweaty, hairy armpits.

those are really good.

i hope that helps.

Thats funny Lofty - you mean you didn't taste hints of nutmeg or notes of caramel on your palate!! LOL Really Good helps and I think I'll pick some up!

For the price, Super Premium Seconds. You just can't beat it.

Ditto what Steve said. Of course they are seconds (but you can hardly tell)of my favs.

These are really good if you can get them for $10/5-pack or less and can let them age for awhile.

http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/lot.cfm?lotID=217371 

Love the Hoyo maddie roth. Just ordered some seconds of those......we will see. But I am sure they will be just as good.

Sancho Panza Extra Fuerte, has a hint of nutmeg, and a note of caramel.

Hoyo/Punch oscuros, Oliva "O" Ole maduros, Partagas Black Bravos.

For me it's Punch, but the Super Prem. 2nds are a close 2nd (how non-ironic).

any body try the saint luis rey maduro rothschild?

very tasty smoke man

for the money its a winner

i get em for about 50 bucks a box

F. Chateau SG

Oliva Bold

Buc Classis Maddie

For me, it's Punch and HDMs...

What jd1 listed as his first choice ...