fishinguitarman
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 11:07:05 AM
ATTENTION NOOBS!!!

YOU MUST BE AN ACTIVE MEMBER OF THE FORUMS TO PARTICIPATE!!!!!!!!!!!

Background: This thread is designed to allow new members to get a good sampler of cigars from an experienced smoker. It also has the underlying intent of fostering the brotherhood whereas an experienced smoker provides mentorship and advice about which cigars are in (their) opinion the best out there. Listed below are “Some” specifics that will help us to get started. And lately it has been about the destruction of Noob’s mailboxes. I am interested in feedback, especially if there is something that I did not clearly articulate.

Explanation: What is the Newbie Sampler?

A specific thread where a Newbie (or anybody new to CBID) can trade for a variety of Cigars. The experienced guy would help the Newbie decide which cigars best fits his tastes based upon the feedback from the Newbie and would tell the Newbie what he would want in return for the sampler. The Newbie would get the “experienced” guy what he wanted and the "experienced" guy would send the Newbie a nice package of assorted cigars. This includes having the Newbie purchase cigars for or from you.

Benefits: Why would I want to trade with these people?

1. First and foremost, time and money will be saved by the new person.

2. The new person will receive a large variety of smokes. All of which have been well maintained and are not dog rockets.

3. Mentoring from an experienced cigar smoker.

4. A start to a good trader rep on Cbid

Mechanics: How is the trade going to work?

There will be a list of experienced smokers that I will maintain on the Newbie sampler thread. A new person would post that they are interested in getting a sampler along with their email address. The experienced trader would post on the thread email sent and reply to the Newbie. The deal would then be handled between the two people and the experienced trader would update the thread by posting Newbie trade completed with (insert tag here).

This will allow everyone to see the progress of the Newbie thread.

Summary: If the trade does not work out where both people are totally satisfied then either or both parties can contact me and I will do my best to make it right.

fishinguitarmanatyahoodotcom – all vets please e-mail or PM me so I have yours. If you know I have it don’t bother. Please stay in for a rotation of 3 noobs then you can decide if you still want to be in.

Remember noobs this is not in any way about how much you send to your vet, there is no need to feel like you need to impress us. This is more about trading credibility and making friends.

Have fun!!!!!!

FGM

fishinguitarman
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 11:07:44 AM
UPDATE!!!!!

ATTENTION NOOBS!!!

YOU MUST BE AN ACTIVE MEMBER OF THE FORUMS TO PARTICIPATE!!!!!!!!!!!

(back to your regularly scheduled program)

Trades in progress:

Papachristou.....Muhren

Reaper0582....scottshoe69

Trkdrvremt....IUROX

Babaki.....nir6van6a

dubleuhb....t33bone

jr_71487....portercolin50

Noobs in waiting...

SUPERTROLLER

SammyETN

DerelictDan

kris_c1986

DID I MISS ANYBODY!?!?!?!?!

YOU MUST BE AN ACTIVE MEMBER OF THE FORUMS TO PARTICIPATE!!!!!!!!!!!

Vets available:

scottshoe69

kombat96

Ok here's a new update...How many of the above 'Trades in Progress' are done deals??

I'll be sending out some PM's and also starting Thread #32...Coming to a theatre near you!

05busa
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 11:30:23 AM
Woop woop
dubleuhb
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 11:58:30 AM

My end going out today,

DerelictDan
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 6:41:29 PM
Can I get some opinions on 5 Vegas?
mceod
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 6:53:21 PM

Can I get some opinions on 5 Vegas?

DerelictDan wrote:

Around here, I'm sure you can get plenty of opinions. 🐴

Which ones are you looking at in particular?

rwilly
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 6:55:51 PM

Can I get some opinions on 5 Vegas?

DerelictDan wrote:

I'm still noobish meself, but have a lot of 5 vegas, the classic was the first box I purchased.

For me, the classic is a good medium cigar, I also really like the AAA and the Relic - they are a bit fuller. 2010s are all I have of the Limitada's and I like them too. Shoot, what's your snailer, I'll send you a sampler! I have almost every variety I think...

sanity1082
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 7:43:07 PM

Can I get some opinions on 5 Vegas?

DerelictDan wrote:

the A's are a good smoke for the buck the AAAs are even better. the miamis aren't bad either. not a big fan of the relic but then again it is all a personal taste thing.

kris_c1986
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 9:35:01 PM
I have been looking around for some really deliscious coffee infused cigars are there any one inperticular i should try?
kris_c1986
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 9:39:15 PM
Can i get some advice on the dog's breakfast sampler is it any good? If not can i get some alternatives please. Thanks

DerelictDan
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 10:03:08 PM

Around here, I'm sure you can get plenty of opinions. 🐴

Which ones are you looking at in particular?

mceod wrote:

I just see it's a pretty big line and there are a diversity of lots to bid on. So I wanna get recommended ones be4 I blow my money lol

DerelictDan
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 10:12:59 PM

I'm still noobish meself, but have a lot of 5 vegas, the classic was the first box I purchased.

For me, the classic is a good medium cigar, I also really like the AAA and the Relic - they are a bit fuller. 2010s are all I have of the Limitada's and I like them too. Shoot, what's your snailer, I'll send you a sampler! I have almost every variety I think...

rwilly wrote:

Ill PM you. We can noob/noobish it up.

Nicar
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 10:14:01 PM
Dan, they are a good start, Would say no more than 3per for about any of them, shoot for closer to 2. I use to have the A and classic around, but not anymore. I also like the Cask Strength, not sure how it would hit my taste buds right now.
DerelictDan
Wednesday, April 13, 2011 10:17:22 PM

the A's are a good smoke for the buck the AAAs are even better. the miamis aren't bad either. not a big fan of the relic but then again it is all a personal taste thing.

sanity1082 wrote:

Thank you! I only have to find my preference. That should easy. Right.. 🤦

DerelictDan
Thursday, April 14, 2011 12:12:49 AM

Dan, they are a good start, Would say no more than 3per for about any of them, shoot for closer to 2. I use to have the A and classic around, but not anymore. I also like the Cask Strength, not sure how it would hit my taste buds right now.

Nicar wrote:

Awesome! I always wonder about price when im bidding. Bombdawgy did tell me to check out CI but i also have a real bad "won't be beat" complex so things get interesting..

sanity1082
Thursday, April 14, 2011 12:28:25 AM
Kris. Look into tabak and java

DD it is easy. What's harder than smoking cigars! All the 5Vs are worth trying at least once.

mceod
Thursday, April 14, 2011 1:40:09 PM
If I'm not mistaken, they have a pretty decent 5 Vegas Sampler floating around here somewhere. I would suggest starting with one of those. My first box purchase was the Classics and I think I still have some of them. Avoid buying to many of one thing right of the bat, taste will change.

FWIW, my favorite 5 Vegas now are the Gold Maduros...

Advojp
Thursday, April 14, 2011 2:06:16 PM
You asked about some samplers... I bought the Honest Pour not too long ago. I've enjoyed nearly all of those. The line up:

The Honest Pour 15-Cigar Sampler includes:

1 - 5 Vegas Class Double Corona (6" x 48)

1 - Arganese Connecticut Robusto (5" x 50)

1 - Bahia Maduro Panchos (5.5" x 52)

1 - Cuban Legacy Toro (6.5" x 50)

1 - Gran Habano Connecticut #1 Robusto (5" x 50)

1 - Graycliff ’G2’ Pirate (torpedo) (6" x 52)

1 - Indian Tabac Classic Arrow (5" x 50)

1 - Indian Tabac Super Fuerte Toro Maduro (6" x 52)

1 - La Estrella Cubana Oscuro ’R’ (5" x 50)

1 - Nica Libre Imperial (6" x 54)

1 - Padilla Hybrid Torpedo (6.25" x 52)

1 - Park Avenue Series 44 Churchill (7" x 48)

1 - Perdomo Lot 23 Robusto (5" x 50)

1 - Rocky Patel R4 Corojo Torpedo (6" x 52)

1 - Torano Dominico Torpedo (6.25" x 52)

I really liked the Perdomo Lot 23 and Rocky R4. Did NOT like the Padilla Hybrid --- I've an Achilles though that I liked. The Gran Habano was very light. Good, but light.

I'm very NOOB so, this is obviously FWIW to you. Oh, and the Cinco Vegas I have had have been good!

rwilly
Thursday, April 14, 2011 2:06:34 PM
I'm going to send him some 5V's I can put together. However, I am not qualified to be a vet, so hopefully somebody will still pick him up for his vet/noob trade. I know Gimbel threw his name in there earlier, but then the whole budget fiasco took place -- Gimbel still in on this or anybody else for DerelictDan?
05busa
Thursday, April 14, 2011 2:19:51 PM
This is to funny