Bands on! Wrong, wrong, wrong.
That is the biggest no-no in the world of tasting/reviews.
Even CA mag does its' reviews/scores blind, it is the only way to judge with no bias.
I had my doubts about these reviews with scores. The scores are so similar, that the difference between the high and low cigars is a range of 10 to 15 points, on a 100 point scale.
What do they need the other 85 points for if everything is going to score between 74 to 89 points?
Trust your own senses. We don't smoke cigars as a panel, we smoke them one at a time, ourselves!