Mr_Vance, not trying to sound antagonistic, but have you tried filling it? I bought some several months ago and they've both been working great ever since (able to bring the Zippos out of retirement, woohoo!).
Anyway, when they first arrived they both did as you described, gave a brief flame then went out. That has a lot to do with how they're shipped, EMPTY! If this still doesn't work (filling them with quality fuel), then yes, you did get a lemon.