My wife and I do my BIL's taxes every year. He makes about 35k and supports a family of 7. He doesn't take food stamps out of pride, but he did get some Obama Phones (I'm not joking). Those phones now sit in a drawer, still being charged to the government. His oldest daughter goes to community college for free, and gets a small stipend.
He paid -$1000 in federal taxes... Thats right, he paid zero and got a $1000 extra back. His actual return was like $5500 back to him for all the taxes he "paid" READ WAS "WITHELD" FOR BREWHA, and his child tax credits.
His heart is in the right place. Three of the kids are his, two are "permanant foster", and are actually relatives from a crazy crackhead 2nd cousin of my BIL's.
This isn't some anecdotal story I am making up, it's the way things are. I think the tax system is about as fair as it's going to get. We can tax the rich ten times higher and it's not going to make a single bit of difference to my BIL. He already pays nothing, and actually gets money from the govt every year on top of all his withheld taxes returned. He, like the rest of the "poor", will not benefit in the least. His "rich" employers certainly will not increase his salary.
Flat tax is not good. Sounds good, but look at other socialist countries (just look at Germany tax system).
gringococolo wrote: