stogiemonger
Sunday, March 9, 2014 9:19:31 PM
I tried rye whiskey for the first time recently.

On a whim, I purchased a bottle of George Dickel Rye Whisky. ( green btl.)

I wasn't sure about it, at first, as I'm used to the sweetness of bourbon, but, I kept coming back for more.

I really liked it albeit, it was very dry, and very Oaky.

What rye whiskey are you guys enjoying?, as , I'm going to be exploring a bit more.

denali7432
Sunday, March 9, 2014 9:28:21 PM
i dont like rye whiskey much, but i do keep a bottle of bulliet rye 95, mash bill is 95% rye..i am going to get my hands on a bottle of rittenhouse rye, its 100% rye whiskey and i hear its one of the best rye's on the market..especially for only $19.99
Plowboy221
Sunday, March 9, 2014 9:42:30 PM
High West Rendezous Rye
gae9jang2j
Sunday, March 9, 2014 9:46:24 PM
+1 on the bulliet and the dickel. Both good for the $$

Also,

Templeton is awesome

Sazerac isn't bad

James oliver is ok

Pricier but right now I have an open btl of old scout smooth ambler rye which is good

Also pricier, I've heard good things about michters rye and will probably pick up a btl soon.

Ive been venturing into ryes myself cuz bourbon is starting to become too sweet for my pallate. Funny thing, I told this to some of the lady workers at the liquor store, that i was getting into ryes, and they commented "how grown up of you" I must look pretty young

Ron should be along soon. Let me go hide in my corner now.

gae9jang2j
Sunday, March 9, 2014 9:46:49 PM
Oohh I heard good things about the high west as well
stogiemonger
Sunday, March 9, 2014 9:52:43 PM
Thanks Fellas!

Keep 'em coming.

danmdevries
Sunday, March 9, 2014 9:59:45 PM
The only decent rye I've tried was Bulleit.

Not a fan really... I've had two other brands, but the Bulleit was the only palatable one. I think Jim Beam Rye and something else rye.... dunno

I tried rye in my beers and it just didn't work well. I catch the same off-flavors in rye whiskies. Something I can only describe as faintly resembling the taste of small insects. Y'ever had a bug get in your mouth and accidentallly crunch it? Usually small beetles, gnats, stuff like that you don't really notice till you feel a crunch and get that nasty dry astringent flavor.... That's the flavor I pick up with rye whiskey. Sure there's plenty of other good flavors, but that one off-flavor just shines through every drop that I put to my tongue.

Others that have tried my rye beers and the recipients of the remainder of my rye whiskey bottles haven't complained of any off flavors, and I've gotten many compliments even from some more critical beer lovers in the family for my rye beers. But for me, no no no no no no no. Worst taste ever.

denali7432
Sunday, March 9, 2014 10:10:04 PM
ive read and heard by many whistlepig makes a great rye, but a i think it runs around $100 a bottle..
sd72
Sunday, March 9, 2014 10:18:08 PM
Thomas Handy Sazerac
05busa
Sunday, March 9, 2014 10:59:29 PM
Rittenhouse rye
delta1
Sunday, March 9, 2014 11:48:21 PM
Tried rye whiskey once when I was a kid (more than 40 years ago) and I really didn't like it. Never had it again.
Whistlebritches
Monday, March 10, 2014 12:00:35 AM

+1 on the bulliet and the dickel. Both good for the $$

Also,

Templeton is awesome

Sazerac isn't bad

James oliver is ok

Pricier but right now I have an open btl of old scout smooth ambler rye which is good

Also pricier, I've heard good things about michters rye and will probably pick up a btl soon.

Ive been venturing into ryes myself cuz bourbon is starting to become too sweet for my pallate. Funny thing, I told this to some of the lady workers at the liquor store, that i was getting into ryes, and they commented "how grown up of you" I must look pretty young

Ron should be along soon. Let me go hide in my corner now.

gae9jang2j wrote:

and stay there damnit.LOL

Even bourbons with high rye mash bills can be a little much for me.I have a bottle of Dickel rye that I try every month or so and it just hasn't grown on me.Don't get me wrong I like rye in my bourbon but in smaller doses....such as the way it pops on the finish in Elmer T Lee and OGD 114 to name a couple.

Ron

riverdog
Monday, March 10, 2014 9:04:57 AM

ive read and heard by many whistlepig makes a great rye, but a i think it runs around $100 a bottle..

denali7432 wrote:

My favorite, and closer to $70.

denali7432
Monday, March 10, 2014 9:43:22 AM

My favorite, and closer to $70.

riverdog wrote:

true, and last night i just noticed they have a rye barrel or cask strength and they want $150 a bottle for it..lol

xibbumbero
Monday, March 10, 2014 10:39:37 PM
Sazrac,when I can find it. Bulleit rye is an XLNT rye as well. X
pdxstogieman
Tuesday, March 11, 2014 12:59:45 AM
I like the Bulleit Rye but if you want a step up try Jefferson 10 yr Rye. It's uncommonly smooth for a Rye Whisky