Most people with tell you if it's within 6 months of box date pull one and smoke it. If you like it smokem until the post 6 months box date mark. Then put them away and let them sleep for another 6 months.
Now for my .02, at some point in time if your expecting to get the full effect of ISOM's you got to put them away for a few years or find some with age (not as hard as you imagine).
A good way to start is buy a box split it into fivers and set aside each fiver to only be smoked in one 6 month period. Every six months you get to smoke another fiver. When you have 10 left it's time to buy another box. As often as possible continue to buy boxes and do this same thing to them. If you started doing this as infrequently as buying a box every other month or every quarter in a year you would have quite stash and if you replaced the boxes like clock work when you had 10 remaining you would always have reasonably aged sticks around.