eodusmc
  • eodusmc
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Monday, May 16, 2005 3:09:00 PM
Has anyone tried these? I'm a sucker for different stuff. I think they would be cool, I guess. Somebody has got to keep the cigar people in buisiness anyway.
keitha13
Monday, May 16, 2005 3:41:00 PM
Yes, very mild, a bit sweet. I can't recommend them over another Candella wrapper because, I've only had the one Iguana. They are not my bag. If you like very mild and sweet, by all means give them a try. I would assume you could get an IT Candella, or a Don Tomas Candella here for less $$$.
madmaxx
Monday, May 16, 2005 3:50:00 PM
just played golf with 2 fellows who told me those were garbage.....but that was their opinions , oh they spit when they said it.....
8trackdisco
Monday, May 16, 2005 4:00:00 PM
Have had the Iguana and the Mutant Iguana. Iguana is super mild, not my cup of tea. The Mutant Iguana has a maduro wrapper. Liked them a couple years ago, but now they taste flat to me.
eodusmc
  • eodusmc
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Monday, May 16, 2005 4:24:00 PM
thanks for the info, because my credit card has been itching.
andytv
Monday, May 16, 2005 4:31:00 PM
well..................you're in the right place them.
todd38sd
Monday, May 16, 2005 5:01:00 PM
totally agree with keitha13.....there are much better candellas out there......i would say buying the iguanas would be a waste of $$$.....

go with the it's...or the astrals...or the don tomas...or look for some hoyo de monterrey double claros.....

all are real cigars...well made with much better materials than the iguanas....if you are going to do the candella thing...do it right.

vfrtwice
Tuesday, May 17, 2005 4:12:00 AM
UGGGGGGG.... i wish this post would have been a few weeks ago. I just pitched 12 of these in the churchill size. A fiend gave me a box last year, i smoked on and thought they might need some rest. Well.. i pulled one out several weeks ago and thought I would make another run at them. It was so terrible i didnt think it was even worthy of putting up on the trade board for "FREE CIGARS" . I needed room in he humi so in the trash they went. Possibly it was just that box, but i didnt think they were worth even giving away let alone smoking.

sorry...I shouldnt have thrown them away.

Keith

mr.harten
Tuesday, May 17, 2005 4:18:00 AM
The Fuente Candelas are one of my favorite yard/golf gars. I bought some of the Don Tomas on cbid a while back but have not tried one yet.
Pinto
Tuesday, May 17, 2005 7:00:00 AM
the Don Tomas is a let down, the "18 years" of ageing took all of the flavor away. A disappointment
jetblasted
Tuesday, May 17, 2005 7:10:00 AM
Gimmick Cigars are usually a waste when it is all said and done . . .
lukin
Tuesday, May 17, 2005 9:36:00 AM
While Iguana cigars might be gimmicks (they look way too radiant green to be true candela's) Candela cigars are not a gimmick. They were the preffered smoke by most Americans until the 1970's. In fact, the candela wrapper was once called American Market selection.

Here is a small clip of an article from CA about them:

"Green cigars are latter-day oddities, but they once were the preferred smokes of Americans, so popular in the United States that cigars with candela wrappers became known as American Market Selection. (Natural cigars, the ones that make up the vast majority of today's cigar market, were dubbed English Market Selection.) From about 1958 to the early 1970s, Americans smoked billions of cigars, and nearly all of them were as green as your front lawn after a May rain. The popular tint was not a function of the use of underage leaf, however. It resulted from a unique process by which the wrapper tobacco was being cured."

I happen to like Candela's on occasion (even though my preffered flavor profile is hard core spicy maduro's). They are very, very mild but often have a grassy (not like marijuana...more like cut grass) flavor to them that I like. I have had the IT Candela, the Arturo Fuente Candela, and the Don Tomas and AStral. Of all of them, I prefer the Don Tomas 18 year aged. I wouldn't suggest that anyone buy a box, but a fiver might be nice if you haven't tried them. If you try a couple and don't like them, then send them to a newbie, generally most of them are intrigued by the odd wrapper and have an interest in trying one.

There are gimmicky ciars out there and for the most part they are a waste of money (La Estrella Cubana comes to mind, or perhaps the Drew Estate Egg) Either they are unsmokable, taste nasty, or are a hassle to mess with. In the case of the La Estrella Cubana, they look awesome in pictures, then you get them and see that they don't look nearly as good but still look kind of cool, then you light it up and it looks like you have been sucking on a cherry lollipop because you have red all over your lips and the ciar tastes like dog excrement.

eodusmc
  • eodusmc
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Tuesday, May 17, 2005 4:05:00 PM
thanks for all the info guys. maybe i will try a different candella. they just look good. thanks again.
Ridgerunner65
Tuesday, May 17, 2005 5:37:00 PM
IT candelas sometimes on bid here

I've found them rather tasty, but not as much as some of the other good candelas

I have tried the DT candela & place it well below other good choices mentioned above

Steve*R
Wednesday, May 18, 2005 8:13:00 AM
The Iguana is made by Felipe Gregorio for a large catalog/internet vendor. I pulled one for chits and grins from a boxpass. It was grassy; almost smelled like ganja when it burned. Frankly, I thought it was awful. Here's my ranking of the branded candelas.

1. La Gloria

2. Fuente

3. Puros Indios

4. Don Tomas/Astral/Indian Tabac when all were rolled by U.S. Cigar Sales...same cigar

5. Flor de Oliva

6. Flor de Jalapa (Nic candela puro, disliked by many)

7. Graycliff Emerald...a nice cigar, but grossly overpriced in candela

There are two house brands of candelas that are very good cigars; one made by Nestor Plasencia; the other by the makers of Flor de Oliva.