Let's get philosophical for a minute. You're stuck on a desert island. You have to pick one particular cigar to smoke for the rest of your life. Giving up all others. What would it be?
And no, Ginger and Mary Ann aren't on the island.

Gilligan started getting rough, the tiny girls were tossed, if not for the courage of the (censored by the British Dental Association), the bed would be lost. I would have to go with Puros Indios.

Yeah...I agree...Puros Indios are the way to go.

My choice would have to be Hoyo de Monterrey, but I might smuggle in a few Puros too.

Mayorga.....sorry guys, I love these little cigars!

If I could find the CAO maduros made in Costa Rica tha would be my pick, if not, I go with the La Flor Dominican maduro #3's....Bring Mary Ann on!!

Are habanos allowed?...I can't believe some of the sticks you guys are picking...No offense...I'd have to pick a Saint Luis Rey Regios or Partagas Serie D No. #4...If they're not allowed, I'd have to go with the CAO Maduro L'Aniversaire or a Bahia Gold

I'd pick the Salazar Diplomate. If not, I'd go with Padron 1964 Anniversary Monarch or Maria Mancini Magic Mountains, or --OH HELL! Why can't I be stuck on Cuba?

Maybe I should have asked this question: If you were stuck on a desert island with Monica Lewinski, which cigar would you pick?

I haven't had much experience with Puros Indios. I did smoke a P.I. Rothschild once. The thing that I remember most is how long it lasted. It seemed to go on forever. I'll have to order some more. Which ones do you guys recommend?

Well I guess that I'd have to go with whatever that bloke Bill C. left her with.

Well if that be the case, And I'm stuck with Monica.
I guess I would have to quit smoking cigars... I mean it is bad enough to deal with tobacco beatles,mold,aging,prices, etc.etc. And now Monica's Cheese!!!!!!!!
no thanks!!!!!!!!
Laterzzzzz
Hog