dstieger
7 years ago

:-k I'm confused... Is it morally wrong to kill someone in anger or not? I thought we were upset with this guy cuz he killed a bunch of people and apparently had no reason other than anger... But now we're wishing we could kill this guy cuz we're angry?

opelmanta1900 wrote:



What's confusing? As long as WE get to decide, it's all good.
opelmanta1900
7 years ago
I guess the "we" is my problem... What if "we" get headed up by a Stephen Pollock or an Adolph Hitler? If "we" are the ones deciding right and wrong won't "we" just eventually decide that nothing we want to do is wrong and everything we do want to do is right?
Speyside
7 years ago
Is feeling the same as doing? There is nothing ambiguous in what I said. The guy murdered people, very different than feeling like murdering him with no intent to act on that impulse.
Speyside
7 years ago
Also, if a LEO had killed him it would have been a justifiable homicide, not murder. So in this instance kill and murder are not the same thing.
ZRX1200
7 years ago
When has kill and murder ever been the same thing buddy?
Speyside
7 years ago
Never, but Opel seems to equate kill to murder unless I misunderstood him. I know I said kill, perhaps murder would have been the accurate thing to say.
opelmanta1900
7 years ago
Jones described a situation of murder... Police shooting a person who is unarmed and has his hands raised in surrender... That is not justifiable homicide... It's murder... You felt like murdering, spey... Don't be ashamed, embrace it...
Speyside
7 years ago
2 separate statements Opel. He was shot by cops and he was shooting at cops. If he had been killed by the cops shooting at him that would have been justifiable homicide. I was not referring to Jonseys scenario then. Also stop thinking you know what I mean. There is a large difference between doing something and wanting to do something but never acting on it. Do you think there should be thought police?
tailgater
7 years ago

:-k I'm confused... Is it morally wrong to kill someone in anger or not? I thought we were upset with this guy cuz he killed a bunch of people and apparently had no reason other than anger... But now we're wishing we could kill this guy cuz we're angry?

opelmanta1900 wrote:



Not "cuz we're angry".

It's cuz they deserve it.

opelmanta1900
7 years ago

2 separate statements Opel. He was shot by cops and he was shooting at cops. If he had been killed by the cops shooting at him that would have been justifiable homicide. I was not referring to Jonseys scenario then. Also stop thinking you know what I mean. There is a large difference between doing something and wanting to do something but never acting on it. Do you think there should be thought police?

Speyside wrote:




No, I think you should be allowed to be as murderous in your mind as you want to be...
tailgater
7 years ago

No, I think you should be allowed to be as murderous in your mind as you want to be...

opelmanta1900 wrote:



Opps.

I did it again.

opelmanta1900
7 years ago

Not "cuz we're angry".

It's cuz they deserve it.

tailgater wrote:


Not according to our laws... Our laws would call that murder... But as I've stated, I think you and spey should wave your freak flags high and proud...
opelmanta1900
7 years ago

Opps.

I did it again.

tailgater wrote:


Not you Brittany...
tailgater
7 years ago
I can't even spell oops correctly.

Friggin public schools.

Users browsing this topic