How do you deny a QB with 2 Super Bowl wins and 2 MVP's?

That was then and this is now. He showed real shoddy skills in the 2nd half. A real leader would've scrapped the coaches call and audible but he didnt even use that weapon. That's why I stated...disappear into the darkness. Become a QB coach. Whatever starting job is out there next year will kill you and the Giants have obviously moved on. The decision to start him will most likely be explained away by the coach...who is on the block too! There's a lot in Giants World that isn't Eli's fault. No WR targets, no D and next to no run game.

With that in mind, I will gladly take the "W" last night, but truth be told, aside from their two last drives, (one to tie the game with a few minutes left in regulation, and the other to win the game in OT), they played horribly.

Singing in my best "Kermit the Frog" voice . . . 'It's not easy bleeding green"

( See what I did there, Frank ?)

Yup HOF

And here’s a little secret. A young man, a freshman in high school........ hehehe

Two good days don't define a mediocre career.

Eli who?

Namath in da HOF............and he only had “one good day”.....

:-k

Take a look at some stats BTW

Horst, you’re probably too young to remember the impact Joe had on the game...and I don’t mean just Super Bowl III. Talkin’ about pro football in general. Besides being Broadway Joe and changing how football players were supposed to look and act, his taking down of the “invincible” Colts proved that the AFL could play with their NFL counterparts. It was huge and it made people change their opinions of the “other” league. Then, when the Chiefs beat the Vikings the next year, the AFL didn’t have to take a backseat to the NFL and could negotiate on equal terms when it was time to finalize the merger.

So yes, Joe may have had only one (...REALLY...) good day but it was a historic day and one that would change the NFL.

All true. And he looked good in nylons. [whip]

I personally don’t think Eli had a HOF career but I’m thinking voters will look at those two SB victories and MVPs and deem him to be worthy, especially considering the fact he beat the, at the time, seemingly unbeatable Patriots. Plus, he’s a Manning and will get extra consideration because of his father and older brother and get in. Ultimately it depends on the person presenting to the committee and whether or not they can make a solid case for him.