Here is a copy of my answers to this question, compiled from threads of the past...
According to market analysis, premium cigars are actually classified as handmade. Therefore, a cigar can cost $0.50 or $50, but if it's handmade, it's considered 'premium'. And then there are machine mades, or domestics. These are your Swisher Sweets, White Owls, Black & Milds, etc and significantly account for the majority of cigar sales.
Unfortunately, your tastes and whether or not you enjoy a cigar do not classify it as 'premium'. Additionally, a premium is not subject to just long-filler cigars, as mixed-filler and short-filler cigars are included within the 'premium' realm, so long as they are handmade.
I think you're question was leaning more towards, "What is a super premium?" This is a whole new animal, and I don't think there really is a definitive line that separates premiums from super premiums. It's probably very subjective from one enthusiast to another. Me? I'd classify top lines from these brands/makers as super premiums:
Gurkha Cigars / K. Hansotia
La Aurora / Leon Jimenes
Indian Tabac / Rocky Patel
Graycliff
Tabacalera Perdomo
Carlos Torano
Camacho
etc...