IMOFF
  • IMOFF
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Saturday, August 13, 2005 10:20:00 AM
Rank these cigars by best to worst. 1 is the best and Ten is the worst.

Torano Exoduse 1959 gold Toro

Vintage Rocky Patel 1990 churchill

Don Diego Playboy robusto

CAO Brazillia GO

Partagas Black Classico

Gurkha legends

Pros indios Reserva Maximus Toro maduro

La Perla Habana classic toro

Montecristo Plantinum Robusto

Perdomo Reserve La Tradicion cuban cafe 'B'

Jeff

P.S. have them all, and willing to trade!

E-mail firedoc51@hotmail dot com

nine999
Saturday, August 13, 2005 10:27:00 AM
CAO brazilia gol- 2

partagas black- 3

gurgha legends- 2

monte plat- 5

torano 1959- 3(could be a 2 if it was fatter)

thats my take- can't wait to see who shoots me down

IMOFF
  • IMOFF
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Saturday, August 13, 2005 10:51:00 AM
Rank all ten 1 through 10 one number per cigar. Just having a little fun, I like to hear BOTL oppions, so I can compare it to my tasts.
keitha13
Saturday, August 13, 2005 10:59:00 AM

Vintage Rocky Patel 1990 churchill

Perdomo Reserve La Tradicion cuban cafe 'B'

Torano Exodus 1959 gold Toro

CAO Brazillia GOL

Gurkha legends

Partagas Black Classico

Pros indios Reserva Maximus Toro maduro

La Perla Habana classic toro

Montecristo Plantinum Robusto

Don Diego Playboy robus

nine999
Saturday, August 13, 2005 11:58:00 AM
oh, i get it now- i thought.....please don't banish me.

CAO Brazillia GO

Gurkha legends

Torano Exoduse 1959 gold Toro

Partagas Black Classico

Pros indios Reserva Maximus Toro maduro

Montecristo Plantinum Robusto

La Perla Habana classic toro

Perdomo Reserve La Tradicion cuban cafe 'B'

Vintage Rocky Patel 1990 churchill

Don Diego Playboy robusto

now, haven't had the last three, but i have had otehr perdomos, and the rp 1992. and as i seem to have some wrappers with don diegos name on it, but i don't remember them...

Big John
Monday, August 15, 2005 5:56:00 AM
Gurkha legends

Vintage Rocky Patel 1990 churchill

Montecristo Plantinum Robusto

Partagas Black Classico

CAO Brazillia GO

Torano Exoduse 1959 gold Toro

Perdomo Reserve La Tradicion cuban cafe 'B'

Don Diego Playboy robusto

La Perla Habana classic toro

Pros indios Reserva Maximus Toro maduro

SteveR@CigarBid
Monday, August 15, 2005 6:26:00 AM
Although this could change from day to day with me...

Vintage by Rocky Patel 1990

Perdomo Reserve La Tradicion Cuban Cafe

Gurkha Legend

Carlos Torano Exodus 1959

CAO Brazillia

Partagas Black

La Perla Habana Classic

Reserva Maxima by Puros Indios

Montecristo Plantinum

Don Diego Playboy

BeatDragon
Monday, August 15, 2005 7:42:00 AM
1 Partagas Black

1.5 CAO

I don't smoke any of the others

8trackdisco
Monday, August 15, 2005 8:03:00 AM
1-CAO Brazillia GO

2-Perdomo Reserve La Tradicion cuban cafe 'B'

3-Torano Exoduse 1959 gold Toro

4-Vintage Rocky Patel 1990 churchill

5-Gurkha legends

6-Pros indios Reserva Maximus Toro maduro

7-La Perla Habana classic toro

haven't had either of these last 2.

Don Diego Playboy robusto

Partagas Black Classico

Montecristo Plantinum Robusto

harriscom
Monday, August 15, 2005 8:04:00 AM
Torano Exoduse 1959 gold Toro............8

Vintage Rocky Patel 1990 churchill.......8.5

Don Diego Playboy robusto................N/A

CAO Brazillia GOAL.......................7

Partagas Black Classico..................8

Gurkha legends.........................Don't like 'em

Pros indios Reserva Maximus Toro maduro .3

La Perla Habana classic toro.............7

Montecristo Plantinum Robusto............5

Perdomo Reserve La Tradicion cuban cafe 'B' ..5

jdobson
Monday, August 15, 2005 10:19:00 AM
Gurkha legends - especially at cbid prices

CAO Brazillia GO - i pay retail for these

Montecristo Plantinum Robusto - recent find for me - i love 'em

La Perla Habana black pearl - changed to the pearl because these are nice

Torano Exoduse 1959 gold Toro - ok, but not memorable

Pros indios Reserva Maximus Toro maduro - i find these to be under-smokey and flat

Don Diego Playboy robusto - too mild, but well made

haven't tried...

Partagas Black Classico

Vintage Rocky Patel 1990 churchill

Perdomo Reserve La Tradicion cuban cafe 'B'

I was surprised by the low ranking her of the monte plats and the high rank on the PI maxima