Mraia
  • Mraia
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 9:27:53 AM
I'm at wits end here. I have a humidor that will not hold humidity. I have used Boveda packs with no luck in getting this RH above 60%, let alone the 72% that the packs provide. I am using 2 packs by the way for about 22 cigars. I am using a HUMI CARE Digital which may or may not be accurate. Salt test puts it at around 69-70% so I think I'm about 5% off accuracy.

I have moved the smokes into a Tupperware, with the hygrometer and the 2 bovedas and the reading is 54%!

Wtf am I doing wrong? Do I need 3 bovedas?? for 22 cigars that seems like a lot doesn't it?

I'm pretty sure that I need both a new HUMI and Hygrometer, but whats with the Tupperware not holding humidity? Am I just doomed to smoke brittle sticks for eternity?

Jsnyder147
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 9:43:14 AM
Hey Mrai,

http://www.cigarbid.com/Forum/c/posts/m/4575097/PSA-on-Relative-Humidity-and-Cigars#post4575097 

Second, have you properly seasoned your humidor? I have had issues with this in the past and I have found that purchasing the 84% Boveda packs, 1 for each 25 cigar capacity of the humidor, works really well. Just set them inside the humidor, close it, and no matter how much you want to check it, leave it closed for two weeks.

Third, invest in a digital hygrometer that can be calibrated. for 20 bucks you can pick up a digital hygrometer and a Boveda calibration kit. This is key to knowing what the RH is in your humidor.

Finally, If you're using Boveda packs in an airtight tupperware, it should be able to maintain +- 3 % of what the Boveda is rated at. I use 4 69% 60g Bovedas in my tupperdors that each have around 80-100 cigars in them. The temp is usually around 66 degrees F and the RH hangs from 66-67%.

I hope this helps.

Mraia
  • Mraia
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 10:07:33 AM
this was very helpful and thanks. I don't think the humidor is properly seasoned. I think I will do the boveda cali thing. As for the Tupperware, my humicare is showing a 56% with a temp of 74, with 2 boveda 72% packs in there, so maybe the rh isn't as bad as I think?

danmdevries
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 10:24:17 AM
Screw wooden humidors unless you really want to spend time maintaining it.

Well-sealed containers with a Boveda, just trust the pack. Forget the hygrometer. I keep my cigars in a Pelican case with a dozen 65% Bovedas and a pound of heartfelt beads, gave up on hygrometers, just let the beads and Bovedas do their thing. When the beads turn all white, I saturate them completely and the excess ends up swelling the Bovedas. As long as I see changes in the beads and packs, I'm happy.

I have a fancy ass desktop humidor. Not China crap, a proper handmade desktop humidor. I treat it like the Pelican case with beads and Bovedas, but it does require a lot more attention, at least monthly I have to resaturate the beads.

Anyway. Bovedas are a reliable two way system. If you eliminate air leaks, they'll do their thing. Forget the meters, gauge by how chit smokes. Once you got it dialed in, in a sealed environment, you're golden. No more worrying.

Mraia
  • Mraia
  • Connoisseur Topic Starter
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 10:30:47 AM

Screw wooden humidors unless you really want to spend time maintaining it.

Well-sealed containers with a Boveda, just trust the pack. Forget the hygrometer. I keep my cigars in a Pelican case with a dozen 65% Bovedas and a pound of heartfelt beads, gave up on hygrometers, just let the beads and Bovedas do their thing. When the beads turn all white, I saturate them completely and the excess ends up swelling the Bovedas. As long as I see changes in the beads and packs, I'm happy.

I have a fancy ass desktop humidor. Not China crap, a proper handmade desktop humidor. I treat it like the Pelican case with beads and Bovedas, but it does require a lot more attention, at least monthly I have to resaturate the beads.

Anyway. Bovedas are a reliable two way system. If you eliminate air leaks, they'll do their thing. Forget the meters, gauge by how chit smokes. Once you got it dialed in, in a sealed environment, you're golden. No more worrying.

danmdevries wrote:

Makes sense. Thanks!

Jakethesnake86
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 10:31:18 AM
Well said Dan I still keep my wooden one full but it’s just to stop me from opening my sealed units

I always have to add somthing to the wooden one. It’s 20 to 30 rh in my house now so keeping humidity up in the wooden one takes patience

Jakethesnake86
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 10:33:38 AM
A sistema klip it brand tupperdor works well. If humidity is low where you live buying an airtight tupperdor will do the trick
Jsnyder147
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 11:53:28 AM

A sistema klip it brand tupperdor works well. If humidity is low where you live buying an airtight tupperdor will do the trick

Jakethesnake86 wrote:

Second this. I have two of these, and they just work. Bovedas and Sistema. You can get them on Amazon for 22 bucks. Almost all of the reviews are from people who use them as humidors haha.

Stogie1020
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 12:37:54 PM
I live in the desert, so I gave up on wood a long time ago...

I use this to keep everything moisty:

https://www.amazon.com/IRIS-Weathertight-Storage-Box-Quart/dp/B003KWJ9TS 

I think I have the 19Qt. Hold three cedar trays and there is a bunch of room on the sides for loose cigars.

Jakethesnake86
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 12:44:48 PM
I have the 74 qt iris it’s pretty fantastic.
clintCigar
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 3:30:07 PM

I live in the desert, so I gave up on wood a long time ago...

I use this to keep everything moisty:

https://www.amazon.com/IRIS-Weathertight-Storage-Box-Quart/dp/B003KWJ9TS 

I think I have the 19Qt. Hold three cedar trays and there is a bunch of room on the sides for loose cigars.

Stogie1020 wrote:

The 62qt of these have over doubled in price since 2019. I was getting 4 packs of these from Walmart for $55 shipped

Edit: This is pretty good deal right here. Anyone low on storage just bite the bullet and get this. You will thank me later. 🇨🇮

https://www.walmart.com/ip/Remington-62-QT-Weathertight-Gasket-Storage-Box-with-Buckles-Hunter-Green-4-Pack/797122209 

LeeBot
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 5:24:10 PM
^ If you buy them for me, I'll send you some REOs.
Stogie1020
Tuesday, February 2, 2021 5:43:33 PM

The 62qt of these have over doubled in price since 2019. I was getting 4 packs of these from Walmart for $55 shipped

Edit: This is pretty good deal right here. Anyone low on storage just bite the bullet and get this. You will thank me later. 🇨🇮

https://www.walmart.com/ip/Remington-62-QT-Weathertight-Gasket-Storage-Box-with-Buckles-Hunter-Green-4-Pack/797122209 

clintCigar wrote:

Holy chit, the 19qt went up by almost double, too!

If you have the Container Store near you they are normal price there... $11 for the 19qt and $20 for the 62qt.

https://www.containerstore.com/s/clear-weathertight-totes/d?q=iris+19qt&productId=10026213 

borndead1
Wednesday, February 3, 2021 10:14:51 PM
Plain old green foam humidifiers have worked better than anything else I've ever tried.
clintCigar
Thursday, February 4, 2021 12:41:16 AM

^ If you buy them for me, I'll send you some REOs.

LeeBot wrote:

u would still owe me money lol

clintCigar
Thursday, February 4, 2021 12:41:53 AM

Plain old green foam humidifiers have worked better than anything else I've ever tried.

borndead1 wrote:

uh??

(edit: I'm gonna assume this is a joke)

Jsnyder147
Thursday, February 4, 2021 6:09:34 AM
Borndead, You know there is a sarcasm smiley you can use. Haha
Jsnyder147
Thursday, February 4, 2021 6:10:28 AM
Borndead, You know there is a sarcasm smiley you can use. Haha
LeeBot
Thursday, February 4, 2021 12:10:46 PM
I use plain foam humidifiers as well. Water and propylene glycol. I haven't tried other stuff because I always found this fairly easy and inexpensive, works well for me. If it's not broke, don't fix it.

borndead1
Thursday, February 4, 2021 9:19:16 PM
I'm not joking. I've tried beads, those jars with little blue/black balls in them, Boveda packs, water pillows, errthang. I eventually came back to the plain old green foam humidifiers in my desktops, Humi-Care EH plus electronic humidifiers in my wine fridges. Guess what those electronic humidifiers have in them? Green craft foam. I don't even run them most of the time. I take the fan part off and just leave the box in there. Checking my fridges now, one of them is at 64% humidity and the other is at 62% humidity. Perfect.