Looking for suggestions on who makes a good looking and good smoking hand rolled cigar that could pass for legitimate in an old west movie production. Preferably something better than Backwoods.

I defer to Alec Baldwin

I'd suggest looking at the brands on this site and perusing their labels until you find something that will suit your needs.

Or maybe go to a cigar retail store and do the same. Just be forewarned... if you're in Commiefornia, you will pay an arm, a leg, and a firstborn child for a decent cigar.

Maybe just maybe you may want to post this question in the Cigar and related forum. 🤔

[ram27bat]

Either BACKWOODS CIGARS

OR

THAT CIGAR COMPANY FROM SCRANTON ,PA ?

PARODI KINGS ?

Parodi - Ammetazzi
Parodi- Especiale

Avanti cigar Co.

Something rolled freehand would give you that old-school, rough and tumble look. The link gives you an idea, but they're probably a little thin for what you want.


https://www.cigarbid.com/a/makers-choice-vanilla/4518317/ 

Was thinking about Parodi, but alas not hand rolled. 🤔

On tombstone they sold some toros at the bar.

---

Red lion cheroot. I’ve smoked them. They’re fire cured if that’s in your wheelhouse. I’m not into fire cured But it fits the appearance

---

Kentucky Cheroots

Parodi's are machine rolled from KENTUCKY FIRE CURED TOBACCO

They look just like the cigars that Clint Eastwood smoked in all those Italian spaghetti westerns...

Guess I'll have to pick up a pack. 🤔

What they all said. Henry Clay Rustic Cheroots are party good and have that rough appearance, but not as skinny as the spaghetti western smokes

J Fuego Origen Originals...rustic looking, 5 pack comes in an envelope.
Haven't had 'em in a few years but used to steal them on line.

LFD Digger Maduro

Ha!

Sinstro The last cowboy

RamRod.........duhh