My lists are in no particular order.

I was overseas for about a year in the late 90's and had a chance to enjoy Cubans exclusively
Cohiba Siglo IV
Cohiba Robusto
Hoyo Double Coronas
Monte No. 2
Partagas SD4

The current list is
Excalibur No. 1 Claro
Excalibur No. 1 Maduro
Fuente 858 Maduro
CAO Flathead 660
Fuente Queen B

And while I always come back to them, I'm always trying something else.

You need to. Haha

Hello all, I'm back from the dead and have been kicking myself for liquidating my collection some years back...

1. Montecristo Edmundo
2. Opus X 888
3. Cohiba Esplendido
4. Padron 64
5. Trinidad (loved every one I've tried, ISOM and Non-ISOM)
*Edit - One to grow on... 6. Punch Grand Cru No. II


* PSD4 fits in there somewhere too, but I wasn't patient enough to let them age. Smoked/gifted 25 pre-matures and still enjoyed them.

Top 5 for me.. I started smoking cigars a little over 10 years ago… so I know what I know and I know what I like…
No particular order..
Nub Maduro
Macanudo Inspirado Red
Kristoff Kristania Maduro
CAO Nicaragua
And I really enjoy the Undercrown Maduro Coronets for a multiple a day, going for a drive to work smoke.

I have several other I love.
Camacho Triple Maduro being notable.

These lists sure explain a lot of the listing here…..jeesh

I'm pretty much a Nicaraguan whore with a maduro wrapper so most anything that falls into that category: Padron, Oliva, Tatuaje, My Father...

I was actually just spritzing my beads in the tuperdor today. (who doesn't like spritzing your beads every now and again?) and ran into some Cupido Criollo smokes (remember these?). I smoked a lot of them when they were readily available but they are now extinct. I have about 8 left from the original blend (box date says Sept of 1999). I should smoke up before they turn into compost. They've tried to resurrect them a few times but they are not the same.

Another long lost fav is the Perdomo 2

My updated top 5

AF Anejo
AF Hemingway Work of Art NT
AF 858 MD
Ashton Aged Maduro
Cohiba Red Dot

I just tried the Montesino Maduro and pretty sure it's going to end up on the list.

Now that I am more seasoned, I feel I should update my list.

1) Davidoff Anniversario
2) Oliva Serie V Melanio
3) AF Hemingway
4) Sobremesa Brûlée
5) Griffins #300

Montecristo Media Noche Torpedo
Davidoff WSC Late Night Churchill
Alec Bradely Black Market Esteli
La Aroma De Cuba Mi Amor Belicoso
Padron '64 & '26 - any size

Not in order, of course.

Ave Maria Reconquista

Don Pepin Blue

Tabernacle

Room101 the big payback

Liga Privada No 9

Swisher Sweets ( everyday American legion smoking)

Giants 5/$2.99
And
Titans 5/$3.29

Lately....@ home

Ramon bueso GENSIS toro
CAO Brazilian 5x56
Diesel shorty 4"
Padilla Cazadores 7"
Romeo oy Julieta mini Reds

Swisher Sweets ( everyday American legion smoking)

Giants 5/$2.99
And
Titans 5/$3.29

Lately....@ home

Ramon bueso GENSIS toro
CAO Brazilian 5x56
Diesel shorty 4"
Padilla Cazadores 7"
Romeo oy Julieta mini Reds

My Father No. 3

Pardron 1926 Maduro No. 6

Dunbarton Todos Las Dias Half Churchill (4.75x48)...discontinued

Drew Estate Liga Privada No. 9 belicoso

Drew Estate Liga Privada UF-13


I'd say this is my top 5, always subject to change though

I’m new to this my fav so far is the Cohiba Riviera

My top 5 changes regularly
1 Juan Lopez #2 The cab I am currently smoking from PSM MAY 13 is amazing.
2 Partagas Petite Corona Especiales TAL JUL 13 Also smoking very well.
3 My Father Lancero Very nice smoke.
4 Olivia Lancero Really good full bodied smoke, with a nic kick of a mule.
5 My Father #2 Just an amazing cigar, for the price I have been getting them at.

I used to smoke more Cuban cigars, but at the price they are going for today, I'll pass.
Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)🍺

No particular order:
• Graycliff 1666
• Victor Sinclair Triple Corojo
• Rocky Patel 2006 San Andreas
• Torano Exodus 1959
• Acid Plush

For me -

Mark Twain #3 8x54
Don Jose El Grandee 8.5x52
Flor de Oliva Gigante 10x66 - when I have time
La Unica #1 Natural 8.5x52
AF La Canones (sp?) 8.5 x52

I'm sure my taste is probably a bit pedestrian and ghetto but these work for me... I'm ready for any insults that may come my way...

The one in my hand is always the best. Unless it's not.

In no order:
Tabak Especiale cafe con leche (with morning coffee)

Aging Room Quattro Maestro

Liga Privada T52

Ashton Maduro

EP Carrillo Pledge