kfarm
  • kfarm
  • Enthusiast Topic Starter
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 4:44:00 AM
As a former professional in the nuclear industry, I've often wondered why the big cigar makers don't irradiate their products. It's a common practice in the food industry (you know.... all those Dinty Moore and other brands that have meat in the box with no refrigeration). The radiation kills all the bad nasties so refrigeration or freezing is not necessary. It stands to reason IMHO, that it would also kill tobacco beetle eggs and larva.

Wait!..... I know..... they're afraid instead of killing, they might mutate into..... cellophane beetles! .... and then, spanish cedar beetles!! LOL!

But seriously, I think they should consider the process. It would leave the tobacco unharmed.

What say you B/SOTL?

(Can't wait for the pot shots on this one! LOL)

Keith

zoinks
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 5:14:00 AM
I think they ought to get rid of sinks and friggin air dryers in bathrooms and install irradiators, but that's just me.

Slimboli
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 5:22:00 AM
Most of those foods that you see that do not require refrigeration are not 'nuked' as you say ...

... they are aseptically packaged. The packaging containers used in aseptic processing are sterilized separately before they are used. The packaging machinery is sterilized using steam, sterile gases, or hydrogen peroxide. The sterilization process is generally monitored by culturing a test organism.

kfarm
  • kfarm
  • Enthusiast Topic Starter
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 5:29:00 AM
You're correct Slim. I didn't mean to imply that radiation is the only method.

I'm just saying irradiation is commonly used

and I think it would work for tobacco.

Slimboli
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 5:38:00 AM
Food irradiation is one means of food preservation that may not be familiar to many, but it has been in development since the early decades of the twentieth century. If properly applied, irradiation can be an effective way to treat a variety of problems in our food supply, such as insect infestation of grains, sprouting of potatoes, rapid ripening of fruits and bacterial growth.

However, it has not yet obtained a significant place in the U.S. food industry. This apparent hesitancy is caused in part by very vocal and active opponents who provide inaccurate information to instill fear about food safety into the public's minds. Many factors of economic feasibility seem to hinge on food industry as well as consumer acceptance, and in turn, have hindered the potential for widespread commercial success of food irradiation.

Commercially sterilize foods, destroying all microorganisms of public health concern (e.g., to sterilize food to the same degree as if they were thermally sterilized (canned); however, no commercial applications of high doses of radation have been approved by FDA for use in the U.S. with the exception of some special hospital diets for immune-deficient patients.)

I guess it would work on cigars ... but the US might no let them into the country.

kfarm
  • kfarm
  • Enthusiast Topic Starter
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 5:57:00 AM
Again.... what Slim said 🙂

I just think it would be a good idea...... some day.

Homebrew
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 6:23:00 AM
I have had irradiated food before.

I don't care for it myself, it seems to take the flavor out of food. A irradiated piece of beef, has a pink rather than red color, and is virtually tasteless. I don't think I want a tasteless cigar.

just my .02

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)

Country
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 7:09:00 AM
I can see it now, All I go out into the field with is my gun, my boots, my MRE's and my CRS (cigars ready to smoke)

Country

kfarm
  • kfarm
  • Enthusiast Topic Starter
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 7:12:00 AM
There ya go Country!

We'll make a fortune selling them overpriced to the Government! LOL

Keith

RICKAMAVEN
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 7:21:00 AM
we used to dry our unerwear on our irradiator.

they were nice and warm when you put them on.

tuckersdad777
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 11:34:00 AM
I wonder . . . . do they irradiate potted meat?
old440guy
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 12:59:00 PM
sounds like a commie trick to get Castro nukes!
jackconrad
Wednesday, September 14, 2005 9:27:00 PM
I MICROWAVE ALl MY CIGARS BEFORE I EAT THEM!
jcwbnimble
Thursday, September 15, 2005 2:00:00 PM
How much is the setup for an irradiation process? I would imagine that the cost might be prohibitive for most cigar manufacturers.

The other issue is, how prevalent are tobacco beetles?

I have been smoking cigar for 16 years and only come across those little holes with about 10 cigars. For me, the problem doesn't seem to be that big a deal. Irradiation seems like overkill for such a small problem.

I could be wrong,

jcwbnimble.

Dr Pepperhill
Thursday, September 15, 2005 4:24:00 PM
http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dbmd/diseaseinfo/foodirradiation.htm#foodapproved 

I found no reason to fear it, in fact, it's a great way to clean up food and has little or no effects on the food it's used on. Mostly it's used to kill microbes; bacteria and some protazoans. I don't know that the methods currently used could be used on insects, but they might be. I have heard that some insects are quite resistant to radiation poisoning. The main benefit I know of about irradiated food is on meat and vegetables. Cut and ground up mammals are especially full of microbial parasites. Many people used to die from tainted meat, especially that infected with certian bad strains of E. coli. Since food irradiation has become a common practice with meat and poultry, the amount of people dying from bad E. coli has plummeted. My sister's group claimed that the irradiation formed certain cyclic hydrocarbons in meat, and was potentially carcinogenic, but the research I saw on that was weak and not conclusive, and besides, the FDA reasoned, the many people saved from E. coli poisoning was so great, that any minor risks were warranted. The radiation itself doesn't make the food radioactive because it's low level radiation, it just kills the germs. If low level radiation (which is cheap costwise) could kill tobacco beetles that would be great. I must say that after a few years of smoking cigars I have yet to see one of the infmaous critters, so maybe the problem isn't so acute as to warrant a move by the cigar industry. Personally, I'm more worried about what chemicals and pesticides the industry may be feeding us without our knowing it.