saturn07
Friday, October 14, 2005 12:37:00 PM
I just smoked my first RP The Edge, so I guess I'll review it:

As soon as I toasted and lit it, it amazingly brought me back to my childhood. The initial taste was just like the Dutch Treats I used to steal from my uncle when I was 12. A dry, strictly tobacco flavor. Anyway, that quickly resolved. It burned nearly perfect throughout. I don't have the taste perceptions of most of the reviewers I read, but the smoke was good; didn't have to pull too hard to get a good mouthfull of smoke but at the same time was not as smokey as I like. I've seen cigars described as 'one-dimensional'...I think I now know what that means. No changing flavor throughout, pretty much stayed the same. Somewhat different that what I'm used to.

Not in a bad way, but it seemed to have no depth of flavor. It was just a good, strong smoke. Thoroughly enjoyed on a friday afternnon.

Of course, I'm cautious about judging cigars (or anything) after just one. My perception seems to change based on my mood, what I'm drinking; hell, even the weather seems to affect my taste. But overall, a good long smoke and I look forward to the second one thats sitting in my humidor for a month or so.

lukin
Friday, October 14, 2005 1:07:00 PM
I am addicted to these things...I have probably smoked a box and a half of these in the last three months. It may be my favorite all time cigar. I can't get enough of them. I am starting to move onto the RP Sungrowns though. I don't know what it is, but Rocky seems to know exactly what I like in a cigar. Padron and Torano same thing, Fuente on the other hand has never really done it for me. In fact, I have only had one or two Fuente's I really enjoyed. The Short Stories are good but frequently plugged, and the 858 rosie was spectacular.
dave97402
Friday, October 14, 2005 1:11:00 PM
I had my first one of these last weekend while helping a friend man his cigar booth at a brewfest. I liked it alot, got a trade going for a few to do some further investigations!!

Dave

ryantp
Friday, October 14, 2005 1:13:00 PM
Great cigar. Thanks for the review...its tough, isn't it?

Yay!! Another cigar post!

myshire
Saturday, October 15, 2005 3:03:00 AM
I'm on my 3rd box of 100. It's about the only cigar that I smoke. Ed
Sfraun04
Saturday, October 15, 2005 5:31:00 AM
Everytime I smoke an Edge, I am put into a feeling of euphoria and deep relaxation. For some reason, it is just so soothing. Pair it with a nice book and a glass of red wine, and that's all I need.

Stefan

Steve*R
Saturday, October 15, 2005 8:26:00 AM
As you all know by now, Rocky Patel's The Edge is rolled for him by Nestor Plasencia. Plasencia's first releases are often great cigars, but he keeps cranking out the sticks, even after the initial supply of superior tobacco has been depleted.

If you look around the net, you'll find The Edge, Edge Seconds, Edge X-outs, and on and on.

It's becoming a crap shoot. I bought 6 of the original 10 ct. boxes of the The Edge torps. They are extraordinary. I bought a 20 ct. box of the CBid/CI CigarFest boxed The Edge. Again...excellent cigars. Then I bought a 20 ct. box of maduro The Edge torp 2nds from another internet vendor. Again...excellent cigars; so I ordered another box. I opened the box and saw a totally different cigar. No oily sheen to the maduro wrapper; the cigars felt light and underfilled. Smoking one---very light draw, hot, irregular burn.

On another forum, there's been a lengthy discussion about the Edge 1sts vs. the Edge 2nds. Until my last box, the 2nds were identical to the 1sts. Now, I'm thinking that, perhaps, the Edge 2nds aren't seconds at all, but just another $1.00 cigar, selling for $2.50.

lukin
Saturday, October 15, 2005 12:06:00 PM
Steve has me all worried now...I feel like Elaine on Seinfeld with "the Sponge" now maybe I will have to take the afternoon/evening into consideration before depleting my Edge stock to make sure that the night is "edge worthy." My local sells more Edges than any other cigar. They go through them like crazy and you can't go in there without seeing someone smoking one. Maybe I'll swing down and throw around some of these ideas and see what he thinks. He has a huge inventory and I wonder when the edges he had were pruchased/ordered
J.Redleg
Saturday, October 15, 2005 2:36:00 PM
Saturn07,

I had the same impression about the Edge being a somewhat one dimentional cigar. Don't get me wrong, I've had a couple of them and I'm not saying it's not a good cigar - but if I want a full bodied cigar, I think I'll stick with the Camacho.

Different strokes...

Herf on!

John

keitha13
Saturday, October 15, 2005 2:43:00 PM
Damn Fine Smoke.......
JJMD
Saturday, October 15, 2005 4:36:00 PM
I agree with Steve R. The original release was outstanding. But subsequent sticks have been disappointing. On the whole, I have found the latest releases to be one-dimensional and flavorless, but still strong in the Vitamin N department. I'd rather have the opposite when I look for a full-bodied smoke.

rodehog56
Saturday, October 15, 2005 6:27:00 PM
Rocky Patel is a true marketing genius. I really don't find his stuff that impressive. He can market his stuff like a snake oil vendor-he can get anyone to buy his stuff! Sorry, not impressed.

Hey! without variety, you wouldn't have a horse race 🙂

n811
Sunday, October 16, 2005 6:18:00 AM
I bought a box of X-outs torpedo Corojo a few weeks ago because every place I looked raved about them. I've had a few of them, and I'm not as impressed as I was hoping. I remember one of the CI staff reviews said this cigar can be appreciated for the complexity of flavor, but I didn't find too much complexity at all (kind of disappointing). However, they are not a BAD smoke - the overall flavor was enjoyable and I don't regret my purchase, but I was just expecting more. Maybe I got a bad Nestor box?? I really wish the manufacutrers would not play this game with their consumers.

I guess I'll have to venture down the Torano road next.

Sfraun04
Sunday, October 16, 2005 7:54:00 AM
I smoked an Edge Corojo last night that came from box featured on special here months ago; half corojo, half maduro. While it was still tasty and enjoyable, it does not compare to the first release. I still have a few of them left from when they were released, and I plan on keeping them around for a special day.

I was never interested in trying the X-Out, Lite, Second, etc. lines. I enjoy the Edge for the flavor it has, and the punch it packs. Nothing more and nothing less please.

Stefan

billreif
Monday, October 17, 2005 5:41:00 AM
I like the maduro alot better

than the corojo...my 2 cents

kdotline
Monday, October 17, 2005 5:55:00 AM
I had the same discussion with my local last week. He has moved several 100 count boxes, and has noticed that the last couple of boxes do not have the same oily sheen seen on the first release. I think I will hang onto the box of first release that I have resting 🙂
lukin
Monday, October 17, 2005 6:09:00 AM
went down to my local yesterday and bought an Edge. I got the same results...no oily sheen, and the taste was changed significantly. One-dimensional and fairly boring. sounds like I am going to have to start hoarding cigars