When I began smoking cigars, I smoked the CAO Gold label and enjoyed it. I do not think I tried the Black until many many months later. I'm sure my taste buds have developed to the point that I would agree with Charlie on the Golds, but the Blacks I think are beyond one-dimensional.
What I do not think gets enough credit among CAO cigars are the L'Anniversaire line of cigars. Their cameroon is fabulous IMHO. I still have a few left bearing the L'Anniversaire label, hehe.
Stefan