First of all, welcome.
I would recommend you try as many cigars as you can and develop your tastes, which I'm sure will change within a year. Therefore, I recommend samplers until you find the right cigar.
I always recommend the Cu-Avana maduro (don't be afraid of the darker leaf, it's actually mild),5 Vegas, and if you want to step up, try the CAO Cx2. It's a medium cigar that you may enjoy.
BTW, I suspect the cigar in Mexico may have been a fake ISOM. Some of which could make even a seasoned smoker puke.
Oh and the Acids, I tried them too when I began and will still have one if the circumstances are right. I only recommend you store them away from your traditional cigars.
Good luck and take a look at the newbie thread, it's packed with alot of good info.