By over the counter cigars, I assume you're talking about Swisher Sweets, Phillies, Garcia Vegas, etc. If so...
The main difference is the way they are made. The cigars listed above (and others like them) are machine made, and often used homogenized wrappers. A homogenized wrapper is a tobacco-paper made of crushed and processed tobacco leaves.
Premium cigars (what we specialize in) are handmade, using 100% tobacco. These can be short filler, long filler or mixed filler. As long as it's made by hand, it's considered a premium cigar, regardless of price or brand.