The Cuban Cohiba Selection Reserve was a collection of about 30 various size Cohiba's (Esplendido, Robusto, Corona's, etc.) which came out around early 2003. I have seen that box being sold during that time in Madrid for about $800-900, and I have not seen that again.
I have heard of some dubious retailers in Mexico and the DR trying to sell them to vacationers last year.
In general, Genuine Cuban Cohiba's are not cheap. The price he is offering is an absolute steal. Hence, if the price is too good to be true, it AIN'T. Sounds like Fakes to me.
The Box may be real though, but Cohiba's for that price...probably not.
Ed