Let's start the debate - Who will win and who deserves it?
I hate to say this because I despise this program with a passion but I believe, so far, Tailback Willis McGhee of the University of Miami will and deserves this year's Heisman trophy. Maybe they should give it to Micheal Vick, he would be a senior if he stayed in school.

Ken Dorsey, only one lose in a career, timely passing under pressure. I'm not a Miami fan, but you gotta give this team credit.

Ken Dorsey, only one lose in a career, timely passing under pressure. I'm not a Miami fan, but you gotta give this team credit.

KINGSBURY...

If they can beat OU this weekend, Kingsbury will be up there with Dorsey and company.

I thought a strong case could have been made for Dorsey to get the award LAST year ... I can't imagine his not receiving it this year. IMO, he clearly deserves it.

I HATE Miami but with the record Dorsey has there is now denying him the award.

I am a MIAMI fan and Dorsey does deseve it. Like it or not this game is all about the wins and losses and he has lots of w's and only 1 loss. A pimp he is.

McGhee...without him Dorsey may have 2 maybe 3 losses this year.

I don't know if Dorsey should win the Heisman or if he will do well in the NFL, but when his football days are over he can always become a successful prison warden. He already has experience controlling the convicts at Miami.

Could Larry Johnson win the Heisman? Over 2,000 yards rushing for the year. He has to be in the top five.

Doesn't much matter! Usually guy with best PR backing wins! I think Dorsey will win.....but the guy who will be the most meaningful to NFL will be USC's Carson Palmer!

Charlie

Dorsey will most likely win because he's Miami's QB. Not to compare him but HEY friggen Gino Toretta won the Heisman..what does that tell you. I think Dorsey is ok but let's face it, you could put another guy in there and you wouldn't notice any difference.