Vol.
Nothing up here with the cozy environment of Appleton Cigar. Close as you can bet in the area of comfort would be a place downtown on Cherry Street. Its called "C-Street". Dark, mellow, comfortable chairs.
Stan & Ollie's on the East side has high ceilings which is nice. The Bar on Holmgren is cigar friendly, so is Anduzzi's across the street. The sell cigars there, but are overpriced even by bar standards.