brockbilt
Wednesday, December 21, 2005 6:17:00 PM
The other day I received The Don Salvatore Digital Hygrometer that I won off C-bid. Before putting it into service, I decide to check the calibration. Using the table salt and a few drops of water method, I put the new Don Salvatore along with my Radio Shack Hygrometer in a ziplock bag. Let them sit overnight, here are the results:

Don Salvatore:

Temp: 73.4 F.

Humidity: 63%

Radio Shack:

Temp: 74 F.

Humidity: 76%

I can't believe my new one is off by 12% on the humidity.....

My question is, would you guys just note the difference, or send it back. The spec sheet says it is accurate to +- 5%

Thanks,

Brock

StogeeBoy
Wednesday, December 21, 2005 6:49:00 PM
Sometimes it happens. You can either do the salt test again, or try and contact customer service. They're good people, they'll try and help you fix the situation.
GDColson
Wednesday, December 21, 2005 7:14:00 PM
I thought you weren't supposed to do the salt test with digitals because it could damage them in some way.
dwallen
Wednesday, December 21, 2005 7:22:00 PM
Well, you'd first have to believe your Radio Shack one was accurate. It could be off as well.

I've done the salt test on digitals. I've never heard otherwise (although I could be wrong.)

A follow-up question: How long does anyone find the batteries to last on the Don Savaldors and the like? I have a few dead ones that I won less than a year ago. Either the batteries are dead or they are.

brockbilt
Wednesday, December 21, 2005 7:37:00 PM
Stogee, They are sitting on top of my shelf right now, out of the bag. I plan on doing the test in the bag again tomorrow.

GD, Have not heard of that….. I hope it is not true. You have to check the calibration somehow…

Dwallen, Using the moist salt method, the humidity in the bag should read 75%. I just figured, if I’m checking one, I might as well check both. The battery had a little plastic tab on it prior to use…. I guess it could be a battery problem.

I hate having to spend so much time checking a $20 hygrometer…

Thanks for the help guys,

Brock

burgess_b
Thursday, December 22, 2005 6:45:00 AM
i always calibrate ALL mine together...you can never be too careful...i think andytv did this with like 13. i would even throw in the dial hygrometer.

salt is the only way i know how to calibrate...if i had beads, i may do a secondary test with them in another bag...that could just be the chemist in me. science dictates that for a fact, the results must be repeated, thus multiple experiments.

try again with ALL hygrometers...it is only 8 hours out of your life.

SteveR@CigarBid
Thursday, December 22, 2005 8:02:00 AM
There's really no need to send it back. If you know how much it is off, you'll be able to keep track of the humidity of your humidor. I have one digital that is 7% off. Another is 9% off. For each of these, and just about every other digital hygrometer I own, I attach a piece of paper noting how to adjust the reading.

It will cost you an arm and a leg to obtain a digital hygrometer that is on the money with every unit produced. As long as it provides a reading, and the reading changes in conjunction with the humidity, the hygrometer works fine.

HKGuns
Thursday, December 22, 2005 9:00:00 AM
Having read the instructions of my Digital hygro....it clearly states NOT to perform the salt test as it could result in damage to the hygro.

"WARNING: This is an electronic instrument. To maintain the warranty of this product and enjoy many years of error free operation, do not attempt to perform the following; DO NOT wrap this guage in a wet towel to test the accuracy. DO NOT attempt to perform the salt test."

As quoted in the instructions of my "CALIBER III" digital hygrometer.

burgess_b
Thursday, December 22, 2005 5:43:00 PM
sooooo...what do you do? an uncalibrated instrument is just a bid piece of randomness!

i would then put it in a humi with a working hygrometer, and calibrate it THAT way...you cannot just trust an instrument that was jostled in transport. you have no idea what condition it was in!

brockbilt
Thursday, December 22, 2005 6:02:00 PM
I agree B_B

Looks like there are more high tech ways to calibrate....but not on my budget. I just noted how much is was off during the salt test with my other hygrometer.

But if my gars go dry, I will hunt down Steve @ Cbid lol

Thanks for the comments,

Brock