primecap
Thursday, December 29, 2005 9:40:00 PM
Hello. I have been enjoying cigars for about 8 years now but I guess I still would consider myself a noob as I don't smoke all that frequently. That being said, I have accrued a decent size collection over the years. Some of these have aged quite a bit (up to 6 years on some). Just wondering what your all's experience has been with aged cigars. I have found some of the milder blends such as casa blanca to be extremely mild, but I also do find that my IT super fuerte's have lost their bite and now are very smooth and tasty. My ERDM's (6 ydears old) have also lost what I considered a bit of a bitter taste and are now almost a bit too mellow for my palate. I do keep the smokes well humidified but am wondering if I am reaching a time for diminishing returns from aging. Do you think that if properly cared for, these smokes will still retain their flavor? or will they simply turn to brown tubes of paper? Any thoughts on your experiences?

thanks

Tuckersdad
Thursday, December 29, 2005 9:48:00 PM
It totally depends on the cigar line, and the storage conditions. Some cigars have to be aged to reach their potential, while others don't need it. Some are aged three to five years before shipping. Some cigars definitely reach a point where further aging not only doesn't help, but the cigar actually starts to become too mild or bland. Extensive knowledge on particular brands is the only way to know. - But - I find the best way is to smoke one at intervals, and see how they're coming along.
burgess_b
Thursday, December 29, 2005 10:29:00 PM
it is like wine, there is a best time "curve"...too soon, not enough tannin (or too harsh)...too late, too much tannin (too mild)...i guess for wine it has an opposite effect.

so, smoke the old gars with young wine and vice versa!

BUT SERIOUSLY, every gar has a different curve...and since taste is subjective, only YOU have the answer.

primecap
Friday, December 30, 2005 1:55:00 AM
thanks for your input guys
redsquid
Friday, December 30, 2005 11:24:00 AM
Something I have noticed (or possibly hallucinated, as I don't know of anyone who has seconded this opinion) is that flavors from cigars will seem to originate either from volatile oils, or more stable minerals. Mineral flavors seem to last a very long time, where the oil based flavors will change, mellow, or even amplify over time. Keeping these sorts sealed up fairly tight should slow things down appreciably. I have never subscribed to the club that believes in 'breathing' their cigars. Unless you plan on smoking them up within a couple of years.
cgbgjr
Saturday, December 31, 2005 5:37:00 AM
I remember reading the following rules of thumb somewhere (but I don't swear by its accuracy):

Peak aging for Dominicans is supposed to be 1 to 3 years, Hondurans 2 to 4, Nicaraguans 3 to 5, and ISOMS 3 to 7.

However if the box has been sealed then the aging process would be slower by some (unknown) factor.

Maybe some of the experts on here can comment further.

My rule of thumb is if it has a yellow cello it goes to the "to be smoked ASAP" humidor. That is one reason I am a "cello on" guy. 🙂

Slimboli
Saturday, December 31, 2005 5:50:00 AM
Excerpt from Cigars International's CIGAR 101 ...

Some cigars, on the other hand, don't benefit from aging. Maduro-wrapped cigars, for example, which are artificially "cooked" or "cured" to achieve the dark coloration of the wrapper, are essentially "fixed," and thus any further benefits of aging have been stunted. It is different with each cigar, but there does come a point when the cigar is optimum and any additional aging simply won’t enhance the cigar any further.

... and reposted (not in it's entirety) from 'another' site:

Assigning fixed blocks as ideal aging time is impossible, each box of cigars is different, and it will respond differently to aging. With that said, here are some ballpark figures to use:

4 Weeks - Cigars should be smoked within a few weeks of being rolled if you desire that "chincales" or "fresh roll" type of flavor.

6 Months - 1 Year - After 4 weeks, I think it is important to allow cigars at least 180 days of rest if they are not smoked directly after their manufacture. I strongly suggest 6 months for milder blends and at least a year for stronger ones. Without exception, cigars smoke and taste better when allowed a year to age.

1 - 2 Years - This is a good time to start smoking those heavier Nicaraguan and Hondurans. This is also the peak period for many Dominicans, and most light bodied smokes.

2 - 5 Years - These are the peak years for most other cigars. Typically the stronger, full-bodied cigars age better over a longer duration. This is why Bolivar Fuertes, Ashton VSGs, and many Havanas are all considered cigars that age beautifully. The same logic applies to cigars of substantial strength regardless of their country of origin.

7 - 10 Years - This is about the maximum aging time for me on almost all cigars. After this point, I find most cigars become too mellow and too pale in body for me to enjoy.

10+ Years - At this point we enter the realm of "vintage" cigars in my book. Many of these cigars will be so flat and boring they are worthless to smoke, while others will take on unique characteristics that will make them enjoyable smokes. One such trait is a musty smell and a taste that is similar to snuff. Another rarer long-term aging trait is cigars taking on an odd scent that is commonly referred to as the "stinky cheese-like smell." This odd reference is due to their pre-light bouquet being faintly similar to a wheel of Stilton cheese. Though it may sound unappealing, these cigars are a delight to smoke and are highly prized by vintage cigar collectors worldwide. Many pay top dollar to secure these smokes. Regardless of the flavor characteristics of vintage vitolas, rarely do any of these cigars maintain any quantitative strength at this level of aging. Also, only the fullest bodied cigars have any chance of being worthwhile smokes after this many years.

By the way, I would be remiss if I didn't tell you that most cigar makers disagree with what I am suggesting. Many are emphatic that there is no benefit in the aging cigars. Of course, it behooves them to dismiss the concept of long-term aging, as it is not in their own interest to retain cigars after manufacture. I concede that they are correct in their contention that their cigars are ready to smoke once they ship them, however, as I stated in the beginning, I strongly subscribe to the benefit of aging cigars. Time allows for good cigars to become great cigars in my opinion. I do not expect manufacturers to retain cigars for extended aging, long-term aging is not a practice for the average smoker, but rather a luxury embraced by the connoisseur smoker.

There are many exceptions to the above timetable - it is only meant to serve as a rough guideline for your convenience. All handmade cigars improve with age, so before you dismiss any cigar as "bad" you should allow it to rest untouched for a while. You will be genuinely surprised how many of those poor cigars blossom into enjoyable smokes. However, please remember that aging cannot improve cigars that are made from inferior or under-cured tobacco. You should only age good cigars as they are the ones for whom you will be awarded from for your patience.

macallan2
Saturday, December 31, 2005 7:55:00 AM
Many non Cuban cigars are just too mild for me when it comes to long-term aging. In General, anything I have that's really powerful and spicy ( the Litto Gomez comes to mind) benefits from aging. I would also say that my maduro LGSsR4's are wonderful with a year plus on 'em. In fact, I plan to purchase 2 more boxes for long-term(5+ yrs.) aging. In the end it's all a matter of preference. If you're not liking the way they're smoking I'd trade them to someone who will for something you're more inclined to enjoy.

Smoke what you like... like what you smoke!

Happy puffin'

Karen53555
Saturday, December 31, 2005 11:22:00 AM
So here is a nube question to the FOG's how do you know how long the cigars have been aged when you buy them? Is there a date somewhere? And if you get them from C-bid in 5 packs how can you tell? Thanks BOTL's
mraven13
Saturday, December 31, 2005 11:42:00 AM
KarenMarie, in terms of non-Cuban cigars...most brands don't put a date on the box of when they were manufactured. And as for 5-packs from Cbid/CI, your guess is as good as mine. I dont' think there's really a way to determine how long they have been aging...as some stock probably moves faster than others.

I say just smoke em' and if they taste "off" to you..or don't burn well, let them sit for a month and try them again..and keep going from there.

rodehog56
Saturday, December 31, 2005 11:42:00 AM
Hey! Not really, we know that most cigars are aged ffor some time depending on the blend and manufacture. We also know that when we get them from eithetr CBID or a local, you can be sure that they have some age on them. I personally like to age cigars for any where from one month to one year. Some cigars get better with age others, just get worse, some just stay the same. You will know what you like. Also depends on the humidity and temp you are storing them at.

As for the knowing the age of cigars when you buy them, you really can't tell when they were rolled. Again, every company is different.

I like my gran habanos after a year and also my R&J Maduros taste better after a year. I know you like the smelly fruity cigars made by Drew Estate and CAO. I can't tell you what age will do for them.

rodehog56
Saturday, December 31, 2005 11:44:00 AM
Com on seester, I thought I trained you better than that Grasshopper!
Karen53555
Saturday, December 31, 2005 11:48:00 AM
Well Bro (thats my bro Rodehog) I always have liked every cigar you have turned me on to...I just got my box from C-bid yesterday...set up the humidors like you told me... and some of the cigs are kinda dry so I am going to have to wait a while..guess like mraven said I just have to smoke one and the proof is in the smoke as they say...
Karen53555
Saturday, December 31, 2005 11:49:00 AM
yes master Brother Rodehog lol