the problem is your cigar isn't supposed to be damp. if it reads damp on the meter then your cigar would probably have just been taken out of the toilet. that's where i would put the dri-damp meter you bought and...flush.
Seriously, I had one of those(not for cigars but for plants) and they were never really accurate. Your cigar shouldn't be moist nor damp, it should be firm and the wrapper should have a nice sheen to it. Got a house plant? see if the meter is reading correctly. The soil should be damp for the thing to work. Do you really want a cigar that's as damp as the soil of a houseplant?
R
JMO