Tuckersdad
Saturday, February 18, 2006 12:18:00 PM
Ever hear of a whole box of stinkos? I got one.

I recently box six boxes of one of my favorite sticks. I'm not mentioning the brand, because it's not sold on Cbid or CI. I rarely have the funds to buy six boxes of anything, but they had a sale. All of a sudden, they offered a 2 for 1 sale, just as I found myself with a little extra cash. So I picked up six full boxes for the price of three. What a deal! And this was no pooch projectile, but a fine cigar, from a very respected cigar factory, aged four years before release, and from a very reliable distributor.

I received them and soon had gone through the first box. They were as good as always. But when I started on the second box - whoa, stinkos! So bad I couldn't finish one. Even when I tossed it they left a very bad taste in my mouth. I eventually tried eight or ten before I decided they were all bad. Meanwhile another two boxes (of another vitola) arrived, that I had found on another sale.

I popped open the third box, and gingerly tried one. I almost hated to light one, the bad ones had been so nasty, consistently nasty. But this one tasted just fine. I'm now working my way through this box, so far so good.

I'm not sure what to do. I don't doubt the distributor will replace the bad box, but do I send 'em back now, or later? I'd like to send any bad one's all at once, but it'll take a good while to get to all of them. What if I find another bad batch on box five or six? But if it takes months, it might be too late to make a complaint, or request for replacements.

So, it happens. Even the best of 'em can be bad sometimes.

Tuck

rbmbb
Saturday, February 18, 2006 1:51:00 PM
I would assume the worst and return the whole lot. Think of the money you would be wasting if boxes 4,5,and 6 are bad as well? I wouldn't let another day pass before I asked for a refund.

R

wvwa34
Saturday, February 18, 2006 4:36:00 PM
Big Rite On R!!!!
Slimboli
Saturday, February 18, 2006 5:07:00 PM
Don't be rediculous ...

... I know the cigars in question, and one bad box dosen't make the rest bad.

Contact CS and let let them know. They are a very reputable company ... and would love to exchange it for you ...

... and equally, they wouldd want back the 'stinkos' to see what the probelm was ...

jcwbnimble
Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:05:00 PM
Hmmmm,

Well I would open all the boxes, take 3 or 4 from different spots in each box and smoke those. That way you get a pretty good idea if the other boxes are junk.

Just make sure to label the gars so you know which box they came from. With my bad memory and even worse luck, I'd get thru all the cigars and forget which one came from which box.