A few summers ago, I drove up into Canada on I 91 to buy beer for a party at my inlaws. I crossed the border and whipped over into the duty-free, because in that part of Canada, the nearest town is miles away. So I load up three cases of Canada's finest and a litre of Glenlivet, and cruise back to the US side. The Customs guy asks if I have anything to declare, and I say "just a couple of cases of beer and a bottle of scotch". He laughs and says, "I always wondered how many a "couple" is. So I pop the trunk and show him...he suggests the next time I want to purchase more than one case, to bring a friend along. I say ok, he waves me through and doesn't even make me pay duty on them (which still would have been a deal).
Bottom line: If you try to bull**** them, they will spot it, and if they catch you in a lie, they can make your life hell.