I read the case:
GIL GARCETTI, ET AL., PETITIONERS v. RICHARD CEBALLOS
No. 04-473
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October 12, 2005, Argued; March 21, 2006, Reargued
May 30, 2006, Decided
Yall should go to the case and read it yourselves rather than relying on the filtered news from yahoo, fox, rush, hanity, NPR, the big O etc. This is my filtered view... worth every bit as much or as little as those mentioned above:
By the way, remember Gil Garcetti of OJ fame.... I'm sure he would never capitulate to dirty cops.
This case involves a prosecuter in a case that was ordered to investigate a sherrifs office because supposedly they lied and had obtained tainted evidence. He did what he asked, concluded the evidence was bogus and his boss agreed........
Until the Sherrifs department got ahold of him and pressured him to change his mind (merit or not I dunno?). The investigator whom concluded the evidence was clearly bogus (and again his boss agreed) told his boss (privately) that he was ignoring the evidence and was only doing so because of pressure or politics. He was sent to siberia (not literally).
The case was argued in October when Sandy Day was still there, then again in March after she left. The Opinion and the Dissent are unusual. It appears as if the dissent was the prevailing opinion until Sandy left and the court changed.....
This was a close decision that I beleve changed in a matter of months because of politics. Agree or disagree with it it will be a landmark case showing a shift in the court.
I think it is bad ju ju, but an equally reasonable person may not.
Its fascinating though if you like politics.