vtbigdog
Thursday, June 1, 2006 5:19:00 PM
I am a fan of Gurkha and had a Sherpa the other day. Burn, taste and constuction were good. Seems like a good every day gar for the money. Are they so or have my taste buds just not developed.
andytv
Thursday, June 1, 2006 5:23:00 PM
If you like it, then it is indeed a good cigar for you!
Sumrao
Thursday, June 1, 2006 6:04:00 PM
yeah dude; the sherpas improve with age...but they are a bundle cigar with a good lable. In fact i found them at a competitors site as the original bundle from the manufacturer for less that a buck a stick.

Andy that was a bit strong for a innocent question?

andytv
Thursday, June 1, 2006 6:08:00 PM
wasn't intended that way..........just trying to say that personal tastes vary.

If you like it.........it is good.

my apologies if I seemed like a ****head.

andytv
Thursday, June 1, 2006 6:08:00 PM
wasn't intended that way..........just trying to say that personal tastes vary.

If you like it.........it is good.

my apologies if I seemed like a ****head.

andytv
Thursday, June 1, 2006 6:19:00 PM
A blind review of the Sherpa Diablo...............

Appearance: Long Filler Toro with a natural wrapper. There are a few medium veins. No marked toothiness.

Construction: Feels consistent; no soft spots. If anything it is a little tight.

Prelight: Smells strongly of barnyard. Clipped with a double guillotine; just removing the cap. Draw is good....a tad firm, but to my liking. Tastes just like it smells.

First Quarter: Primary flavors are Cedar and Leather. This doesn't seem to be a very full bodied smoke yet. A minute or so in, the leather diminishes and a woody strawlike taste is in the forefront with a bit of toffee just barely there. Burn is spot-on thus far. About an inch in, I'm starting to taste a little bit of tobacco spice. The burn is starting to go to hell; canoeing about 1/4” out of whack. I touch it up with my Z-plus insert and head to the second quarter.

Second Quarter: The flavor profile is the same; leather, cedar/straw, and a little spiciness...not much, this seems pretty mild to me. I can see a void where the burn was canoeing; it appears that a substantial vein is rolled into the binder/filler. The ash dropped at about 2”; leaving a hard pointed vein behind in the center. The flavor is good, but I'm taking about three good slugs before it satisfies.

Third Quarter: No big difference in flavor so far, except it is getting a little sweeter and toastier. The draw is getting tighter and I'm picking up a little bitter tarriness, so I recut. The tarriness has improved, but it is still a little plugged. Sweetness is increasing, as is the bitterness. Despite the bitterness, I am enjoying this a little more. Perhaps my brain is ascribing a full-bodied attribute to the bitterness.

Last Quarter: I rinse with a swallow of light beer and proceed. A new flavor profile is becoming apparent. There is a definite brandy/cognac flavor with a hint of vanilla and some sourness. If I hit it hard, the leather flavor comes back into the picture. This stays consistent until the last 1”, and I am finished.

OAL: Despite the diversity in flavor, this seemed pretty mild. It took a fair amount of concentration to discern the flavors I've described.. I don't smoke many mild/medium cigars, but I would have guessed Macanudo until the construction and draw started to fail. I am thinking that maybe this is a Cu-avana or other Matasa product?? I probably would not buy these, but would recommend them to mild smokers.

If this cigar cost more than $5, then I have just made an ass of myself.

J.Redleg
Thursday, June 1, 2006 6:27:00 PM
BigDog,

Ironically, last week I pulled one that I let rest for a year or so (Ok, I found it at the bottom of the humi).

Time didn't do much to change the mild body, but the flavors were more noticeable.

I wouldn't go out of my way for them, as my tastes lean to more medium/full flavored cigars, but I do give them credit as being a good mild cigar.

Enjoy them while you can.

nine999
Thursday, June 1, 2006 8:29:00 PM
hmmm....i know a lot of botl's don't care for these. thats cool, i don't care for opus x.

i've always had a softspot for sherpa's. i bought into these when i was just starting out, and was more concerned with price. since then, i continue to bid (low) on these whenever i see them, especialy the mystics. i think i like THOSE even more.

but remember, the longer you let them sit, the better they get. i'd suggest no less than 6 months, but 3 will do on a pinch. i try to keep 3-4 on hand, at the bottom of my humi at all times, sometimes more, often less. expecting a 5'er i won for 6 bucks- (can't beat that with a rubber di...)

never had the diablo. heard they were spicy, and i don't care to much for spicy stogies.

what does it all mean? like that JERK andy said, if you like 'em, they are good for you.

now, a little wiser, i pretty much only buy "premium" cigars. but i will bid on these.

try the mystic.

nine

nine999
Thursday, June 1, 2006 8:36:00 PM
by the way, here is a grand opportunity!

http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/lot.cfm?lotID=355143 

nine

Sumrao
Thursday, June 1, 2006 9:29:00 PM
Thats amazing andy...cant believe that guy could write so much about a Sherpa. A review tosser!!

A new degree of splitting hairs, no less describing it.

loved the part about cutting it with a guillotine. I need a towel.

CWFoster
Friday, June 2, 2006 1:53:00 AM
Sumrao, it was a BLIND review. The person writing it didn't know WHAT he was writing about. It's about the best way to get a really fair evaluation/opinion on a cigar, send it to someone whose opinion and taste you respect, without the band, and ask for a review. If you're new on here, you probably never read one of Cavallos reviews. Several of us told him he needed to go to work for Cigar Aficionado, or Smoke Magazine! He wrote OUTSTANDING reviews! He could almost make you taste the cigar he was describing! He's no longer with us, and is sorely missed.
CWFoster
Friday, June 2, 2006 2:03:00 AM
Oh, and for what it's worth, the Gurkas and Sherpas are both manufactured by Carlos Toraño Cigar Comapny! They make a few tasty ones, a few mild ones, but I haven't found a rocket in the line!
cgbgjr
Friday, June 2, 2006 2:12:00 AM
I like them. I did not find the diablo spicy at all--I found it a mellow tasting smoke like the regular line.

The Diablo part is that it is stronger (on the head-spin meter) than it tastes--a devilish combination. 🙂

nine999
Friday, June 2, 2006 5:21:00 AM
i'll have to try one. any traders out there?

nine

Sumrao
Friday, June 2, 2006 7:21:00 AM
sure nine, I have some one year old diablos and som east india even older...whatca got??
nine999
Friday, June 2, 2006 8:23:00 AM
shoot me an email

nine999 at netscape.net

TROY6311
Sunday, June 4, 2006 9:01:00 AM
Great review - I like the sherpa but normally early in the day - may tastes have changed over the years and I lean towards stronger sticks but keep a good supply of sherpas - also like the gispert nat.