My opinion is to stick with the main labels, and avoid the one-offs and no-names. There's a reason why Rocky Patel and CAO are so highly sought, and that is "consistency". Sometimes you can find a "diamond in the rough" with trying a number of cheaper, unknown brands, but that's pretty rare. They always have something wrong with the offering: whether it's construction problems, flavor inconsistencies, or whatnot. When you spend more money on the bigger name brands, you're getting a higher-quality product...ideally.
I agree with one of the posters that said "start with mild-to-medium smokes and work up," as after a time your palette will change, and you'll acquire a taste for cigars. Secondly - in theroy - you'll be able to build up a tolerance for the higher nicotine levels that fuller-bodied cigars often bring to the table.
(I say "in theroy" because I just had a Joya de Nicaragua Antano 1970 Churchill that nearly kicked my a**. Nearly...)
As you might ascertain, I like CAO almost across the board. I also like Baccarats (though you'll have to age them for about 6 months), Hoyo de Monterrey, La Finca (relatively unknown brand), Onyx Reserve (which is a good starter for a person moving up into a full-flavor cigar), Savinelli, Por Larranga, and several others.
Oh, and one last piece of advice: don't worry about what other people think of your selection. Taste is the most subjective part of cigar smoking. Some people like a straight tobacco taste, others like the various subtle flavors that extensive curing produces. One does not always trump the other, nor is one preferred over the other. Beauty - for lack of a better word - is in the eye of the beholder. What isn't subjective are the standards of the brand in question as it relates to consistency, quality control, and so on. You don't want to pay some $100.00 for a box of cigars, only to discover you've got to toss half of them because they taste like Pine Sol...