Kelly, for the most part you are correct, most light & heat from a burning cigar are the result of the transformation of chemical and not nuclear energy, however a very tiny amount of mass is lost in everyday exothermic chemical reactions from whatI understand (which is little).
Einstein's himself argued that when an object emits light it becomes lighter and decreases in mass.
From this site: [http://tinyurl.com/ghxce] "If you burn a ton of fuel, maybe a few micrograms of matter disappear and are converted into energy."
From this site: [http://tinyurl.com/j45t2] "the energy released in chemical reactions when an average person shovels snow for one hour amounts to a mass loss (by E=mc2) of only 10 billionths of a gram."