W. R.
  • W. R.
  • Rookie Topic Starter
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 4:30:00 AM
I have been given two different ones in the last 3-4 months, both pretty nice but no idea what they were. Anyone have thoughts on these things, thanks
usahog
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 5:00:00 AM
This thread has wide open spaces??

were they Red Dot? Yellow Band Dominican? Suspected Cuban by the lable?

Were they Robusto size, Corona size, Penetalia size?

MPO I Love the fell outa Cuban Cohiba's!

and don't care much at all for the others

Hog

docrks
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 6:44:00 AM
I know exactly what these Cohiba sticks were.....

I am communicating the answer to you by mental telepathy..... Transmitting NOW !!!!!!

Sardious
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 7:25:00 AM
assuming they were the legal to buy ones....if it was dark wrapper and spicey tasting it was probably the Extra Vigaroso....those are decent sticks. If it was milder and smooth it was probably just your normal Cohiba. They are always a quality stick even if they are not my thing
W. R.
  • W. R.
  • Rookie Topic Starter
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 8:29:00 AM
Ok, Ok, my bust, should have worded my question better, I forgot that this area of interest collects newbies turned snobs with too much time on their hands in, oh what, 3-4 months. No, I do not know what they were, both mild and nice. I was asking for comments on the Cohibas in general not the two I had.
Lowman
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 8:37:00 AM
W.R.,

As Hog stated above, there are several different cigars that use the Cohiba name. Each have a different flavor profile. If you describe the band, that will give a better understanding of what you are asking and people may be able to help you better.

Herf On!

Low

Nutttttttttty
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 10:27:00 AM
Man W.R. that was a pretty big statement. You go and insult people by calling them noobies and know it alls that trully don't know anything. Well buddy you stepped in it. There is no reason to come in and insult people that are genuinely trying to help you. The fact that you are confused about cohibas is fine. But nobody is being a snob or a noobie here except you. Just try to tread a tad lighter when you are in new territory. The people here can really be a source of knowledge and help but you have to let them.

I like cuban cohibas but I think they are overhyped and overpriced. Some people just swear by them and say they only smoke cuban cohibas. In my experiance those are the real snobs who know nothing at all about cigars. I love to get that answer from people when I ask them what brands they prefer. If the answer is I only smoke cuban cohibas I immediatley jump to the conclusion this guys is a jackass and full of sht. I could be wrong in profilling but as my boy VFR has taught me profiling can be alright.

The red dots are again a fine cigar but I don't smoke them very often becuase I like other brands more with a much smaller price tag. People are willing to go everboard with the cohiba name and pay through the nose.

The Crap yellow band cohibas are just that crap. The have basically no prelight scent to them and just taste like paper or something when they are smoking. The ones I have had burn very nicely and are pretty cheap atleast in relation to the other cohiba brands. But they ain't worth it. I might smoke one if it was free and I was out in the hills without a cigar shop for a hundred miles but besides that I won't do that again.

Club3006
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 10:37:00 AM
Wow, W.R.! Do you own a shpo?
Matt76
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 11:22:00 AM
nutty I agree with you 100%. I was working a party a cpl weeks ago and was smoking a 5vegas A limitado. Some guys comes up to me and goes "O you like cigars", I responded by saying yup sure do. He goes "is that a cuban", I said nope. Then he goes "OH I WOULDN'T SMOKE ANYTHING OTHER THAN A CUBAN COHIBA"

I said good for you and went on enjoying a great smoke for a lot better price.

usahog
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 12:03:00 PM
Well, I don't think I'm an jackass but I can play the part pretty well sometimes ;0)

If you price the Red Dot cohibas to the Cuban Cohiba

lines.. you'll find price wise your not paying much at all in difference.. but as I said above I love the CC's and prefer them and will spend when it comes to spending that little extra for what I like...

I also smoke Padron's, Torano's, Perdomo's, HDM's and the like with no hesitations and enjoy them very much... but dollar for dollar Cuban Cohiba's are my Favorite of all in the cigars...

Hog

Cycleman
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 1:51:00 PM
I like all Cohiba's I have been blessed with to smoke.

Even a few fake ones were good sticks.

Nutttttttttty
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 2:54:00 PM
I play the jackass part quite well as you can see. Got nothing against it being your favorite smoke. I think many people feel this way. It's just when people act like you don't know jack because you like nicaraguans. But I know you aren't one of those Mr. Hog. Truth is I'm to broke for those to be my favorite smoke. 😉 So Thank God I can enjoy the bottom of the barrel. Please don't let my palate improve anymore. Please.
Nutttttttttty
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 2:59:00 PM
Hog can you suggest a torano and a HDM for me to try. Padron and perdomo are my favorites. I like the Maduro X000 series and the perdomo squared maduro. But people really seem to like these toranos so I figure I have to give em the old college try. Not sure why I haven't tried a HDM they seem to have everything I am looking for in a cigar.
pacman357
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 3:34:00 PM
Love the CCs. Whoever put the Cohiba name on that red dot crap should be neutered. Without anesthesia. In front of his kids.
Cycleman
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 5:25:00 PM
I SWEAR it wasn't me!!

Wooweee....... and glad!

usahog
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 9:52:00 PM
Nutty,

just got back to this post... I really like the Torano Signiture Series, the Exodus 1959's are good as well (better with age) and the 1916's in the cedar sleave's

HDM's nowadays I enjoy the Excalibur 1066 line with the Merlin being my strong preference...

also the Rothschild Maduro's are pretty good with some age...

Hog

usahog
Wednesday, September 6, 2006 9:58:00 PM
Oh and another on the Torano line.. The *Tribute* 2003 blend though... I don't care to much for the 2004 blend..

Hog

Slimboli
Thursday, September 7, 2006 5:31:00 AM
W. R. --- there is not such thing as a Cohiba in general.

Are we talking about cigars that come from Cuba? Or are we talking about the 'yellow band' from the Dominican Republic? How about the Cohiba Red Dot by General Cigar's Diaz y Cia?

All have different wrappers, fillers and binders (from different countries) ... so you can't just blanket them all in one heap ... and expect a consise answer to your question.

There are so many folks here that have been 'around the block' with cigars for more years that you could imagine, and have forgotten more about cigars that you probably persently know ... to insult them because you can't be more specific in your query ...

... is just lame.

Slimboli
Thursday, September 7, 2006 5:36:00 AM
Maybe this might enlighten you ...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cohiba_ (cigar_brand)

W. R.
  • W. R.
  • Rookie Topic Starter
Thursday, September 7, 2006 6:47:00 AM
For Nutty and Slimboli, thank you, you both gave me something to work with. Since I do no know what I had, just liked them, I probably should not spend any of my money on learning about them, not at this point at least. There are plenty others on here that are relatively inexpensive and that I like equally well. For anyone who might have gotten insulted, I will apologize, certainly was not my intent.