Buckwheat
Thursday, October 26, 2006 11:40:00 AM
Just read this review at another site.

"Bitter-bean overtones, peppery spice with a slightly creamy finish, mixed with rich cedar nuances."

Give me a break.

snowwolf777
Thursday, October 26, 2006 11:49:00 AM
Notes of porta-potty, mixed with the playful undertone of aged mouse turds.
SteveR@CigarBid
Thursday, October 26, 2006 11:55:00 AM
Funny...sometimes I say the same thing when smoking a cigar. Every now and then, a very odd flavor will jump out and dominate your taste buds. Sometimes this flavor can be defined right away; sometimes it takes a little bit of time. But, once you figure it out it becomes quite obvious. I've noticed this with things like cinnamon, red wine, nutmeg, coconut, and several others. But, I’ve never tasted pencil shavings.
MACS
Thursday, October 26, 2006 12:08:00 PM
My taste buds are not as discerning as some folks.

I usually have 2 categories... Like and dislike.

Rarely do I smoke a cigar where a certain recognizeable flavor (to me) shows through, but there are a few.

PLPC's to me taste a bit like caramel. Not like you were chewing a piece, but kinda that flavor. El Principe's - Chocoalte, or cocoa. And Cohibas usually give that fresh cream flavor... like you took a sip of heavy sweet cream... that aftertaste.

Aside from that, my palate just doesn't get all the different, nutty, toasty, peppery, cedar, etc... flavors.

For the most part, I judge a good cigar AFTER i've smoked it by the pleasant or unpleasant aftertaste. Sometimes the unpleasant will poke through WHILE smoking and then you just pitch it.

pabloescabar
Thursday, October 26, 2006 12:08:00 PM
I've had pencil shavings but have never tasted them in a cigar.
teedubbya
Thursday, October 26, 2006 12:42:00 PM
Sometimes towards the end of a cigar I taste ear wax

but not on the cigar, its usually after picking my ears

Pelchy
Thursday, October 26, 2006 12:50:00 PM
This is funny, I was just going to post something about cigar tasting. It always cracks me up to read what they write.

I smoke two sticks a day and sometimes more on the weekend. There has never been a time that I could detect a "cedar undertone" or "hint of berries". Its either good tobacco or its not! It tastes like good tobacco or it tastes like crap! Granted cigars from different origins have different flavors (Honduran vice Nicaraguan) but I've never been able to assign a cigar flavor to anything other than tobacco!

For me the first thing is if it draws nicely. Not loose so that it burns like paper, and not so tight that you feel like you're trying to suck a golf ball through a garden hose, but easily so you get a lot of smoke. Then I determine if I like the flavor. If those two things are in line then its a good smoke!

After that the only thing that could possibly ruin it is the construction of the cigar and if it has been properly humidified. In the winter especially, I get a fair number of them where the wrapper cracks or starts to unravel.

Anybody else on board with this?

snowwolf777
Thursday, October 26, 2006 1:18:00 PM
Truthfully, the only thing I've ever tasted is pepper, what I presume to be cedar, and occasionally cocoa. Even then, I just go off "like" or "don't like". I can taste many nuances in wines. For some reason I can't with cigars.
pabloescabar
Thursday, October 26, 2006 3:04:00 PM
Pelchy you really know what crap tastes like ?
edsbar60
Thursday, October 26, 2006 4:08:00 PM
I'm with MACs on this one. I can't differentiate flavors except for Cocoa/Chocolatey and I understand creaminess. But what the hell's "leathery, woodsy, cedar undertones,cashew, walnutty, peanut buttery, jamaica almond fudge, pralines-n-pecan, with nutty hints of berries and a cherry on top"?

It's just good or it ain't for me.

nickgonzo
Thursday, October 26, 2006 5:49:00 PM
IDK, like you guys I cannot point out exactly what every cigar "tastes" like. Either I like it or I don't.

But on certain cigars I taste things that are very specific in my mind, like certain smells that I have encountered. For example, the CI Orange Label... I think it tastes very woodsy and toasty. Like someone was burning wood chips in the forrest. Know what im sayin

J.Redleg
Thursday, October 26, 2006 6:00:00 PM
I don't know whether I'm lucky or not? I can usually pick up hints of different flavors, usually I can't figure out what they are, but the obvious ones like chocolate, nuts (can't figure out which one), caramel, pepper, etc.

I've found some cigars that others love, to be ok but lacking that extra flavor that makes it a great cigar to me.

Sfraun04
Thursday, October 26, 2006 7:42:00 PM
Guess you never read one of my reviews before LOL
ianmac864
Thursday, October 26, 2006 7:56:00 PM
I find this to be a little humorous...I made a similar post about this exact same subject three or four weeks ago, and many people jumped in to explain to me how you either have the ability to determine these subtle flavors, or not. Maybe I wasn't experienced enough to recognize these flavors yet...try exhaling through you nose, etc. I still say that if these people can decern such suptle nuances, they should be taste testers for a food company. I, on the otherhand, I have tried many different cigars over the last three years, and all that I can recognize from a cigar is a range of bad to excellent tobacco flavor; bitter, spicy, salty, grass, harsh, mild, medium, or strong, and that is it. I'm going to have to call B.S. on most of these descriptions...especially pencil shavings, acorns, dirt, metal, etc...puleeese. However, if you can truly taste these things, then I'm happy for you; just because I can't pick up these flavors certainly does not mean that you can't. However...I really think that some people just get carried away sometimes, trying to impress other people with their experience and obvious expertise. They hear all of these flavor descriptions given, and they feel that if they don't experience them as well, their fellow herfers will think they are not educated in the obviously fine art of cigar smoking. No insults meant, that is just what I believe.
Pelchy
Friday, October 27, 2006 4:36:00 AM
Why yes I do know what crap tastes like! I made the mistake of lighting up one of those flavored turds they sell in most convienient stores! That sobered me up right quick!

:>))

Sardious
Friday, October 27, 2006 5:19:00 AM
I am not sure what "bitter-bean" overtones are but the rest I have learned to be able to taste. A floral type taste, ceadat oak, haselnut, many things. a "Cedary overtone" just means that there are many flavors but the cedar type taste is a constant part of the tast though not super dominant. It is not that wierd. At first I could not tate many different things, I liked some things and I knew the taste was different but I could not have explained what was different. Now I can. Everyone picks up tasting to some degree as they go
blackdog2000
Friday, October 27, 2006 5:27:00 AM
Yeah- Emperor's new cigar...

Well if you're trying to describe subleties, you have to rely on some approximations.

This all comes from the fairly ridiculous lengths that the wine reviewers and connoiseurs go to. All the "overtone, undertone, midnotes and lingering finish with lemom pledge notes" stuff has started to become more common...

Buckwheat
Friday, October 27, 2006 5:33:00 AM
...and more comical.