Yes, the Cuestra Rey no. 11 Belicoso centenario does taste like tree bark with a finish of old shoe polish. As a matter of fact, the entire Cuestra Rey line sucks, althought I have yet to smoke one of them.
And yes different size from the same brand/line will taste differently.
Now, if you will, try the Cuesta-Rey Centenario No. 11 or the Cuesta-Rey Centro Fino No. 11, you will notice the difference. A much better cigar.