I've tried the punch, but it's not consistant enough, especially with sticks that are not known for their loose draw.
I've got an expensive V-cutter, and it works Ok until the blade starts to dull - then all it does is rip apart the cap.
I eventually resorted to using the ole incisors (I can actually imagine some of you cringing as you read this) for a long time, mainly because I'm a cheap SOB.
I'm using a gillotine now, and I'm able to get better control on the draw by adjusting where I cut. If I know the stick is going to be loose, I cut way up on the cap. If it's tight, I go further down. Plus, I can use the cutter to slice the burnt foot off of a half-smoked stick, and reserve the rest for later. Can't do that with either a punch or a v-cutter.