nine999:
I'm to blame for the Brazilia comparison. I hold my head in shame...
My original experience was the Tubos, and I've got to say they were very much like Brazilas.
I've since purchased a box of churchills, and they've yet to stand up to the Tubos. I myself was a bit disappointed by this, though I can't explain way. They've got neartly the same ring gauge, and I'm assuming they've got the same filler, and definately the same wrapper. However, there was a distinct difference in flavor. I'm thinking is has something to do with the lots used to make each, although I can't see how that could be.
My comparison is against the Samba, and they were pretty close, in my estimation. Maybe my tastebuds just plain suck.
Either way, seeing that you were an Onyx Reserve fan (as am I), I figured this would be a lower-end smoke that was compatible for your tastes.
Still, they're now a go-to stick for me, and I've got no complaints. Sorry they weren't what you expected.