Sardious
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 12:49:00 PM
SO I read around on the stories of cigars and I notice that a decent amopunt of cigars I like have been aged in oak. listening to the audio files some are oak casks that are made for alchohol but the cigars guys buy a few. Some are old rum or wine barrels and casks. Edicion de Silvio is one for example.

So I wonder to myself. What if I made a Humidor, something smaller, maybe a 75 to 100 or maybe 150 count and take 2 sticks of various brands in the main humidor and stick them in the oak humidor for a few years. I wonder how it would affect the taste and would it be a good affect in general. Good even if judt different but not in a negative way. I have no wood working skills. Nothing along the way of say Mr Hog, but I may have to work with my dad or some people that do just to try this out.

Just wiondering what others thought of the idea.

jpotts
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 1:46:00 PM
I doubt you'd pick up any flavor, with the exception of maybe a slight vanilla note. Cedar is typically aromatic, released from the resins inside the wood, which is one of the reasons for purchasing it.

Imitaion vanilla, by the way, is made from wood (I beleive specifically oak).

You might want to check and see if the barrels are pre-charred, or left as is. Some beer brewers buy oak casks to condition or ferment their brew, but they are carred inside first to eliminate contamination, and the neutralize any flavor contamination (I'd think that charcoal would add something to the flavor, but that's what I read). As far as humidity control, most barrels rely on the swelling of the wood to provide a water-tight seal, so you mat be out of luck there.

Some humidors have mahognay linings, which I sort of doubt would contribute anything to flavor. Then again, I've never had a humidor lined with mahogany, so I'm no expert.

usahog
Tuesday, November 28, 2006 2:12:00 PM
Red Oak, Smells like Dog **** or worse.. when working with it.. leaving it raw, unsealed would give the flavor/smell of the same into your cigars I would think??

Sardious,

I think what you might have read, was these Barrels were used to age/fermenting the cigar leaf prior to them being rolled?

Cherry on the other hand has a nice fruity smell to it while being worked

the reasoning for Mahogany or Spanish Cedar is not only for the aroma they produce but mainly for the porous aspect to help regulate/control the humidity in the cigars...

Hog

happy1
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 4:24:00 AM
stay away from red oak if you cut much off it or are around it like at a saw mill everything starts to smell like urine
Sardious
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 5:09:00 PM
"I think what you might have read, was these Barrels were used to age/fermenting the cigar leaf prior to them being rolled?"

I think that is what I read and heard. I just did not know if it would so anything for long term againg of a stick. From what I am seeing the answer would be no. Or nothing good anyway.

usahog
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 6:50:00 PM
Seal Red Oak or White Oak is very Beautiful wood..for the outside of the Humidor.. Especially if it is quarter sawn wood...

Interior lining should be Spanish Cedar or Santose (sp) Mahagany though for best humidification for cigars...

Hog

jpotts
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 7:44:00 PM
I think that the only type of oak used for things like liquids and such is White Oak.
bsevern
Wednesday, November 29, 2006 8:45:00 PM
jpotts I'm surprised that imitaion vanilla is made from oak, seems like it would be cost prohibitive.
jpotts
Friday, December 1, 2006 1:05:00 PM
Imitation vanillia can be made from a variety of woods, however, I believe the chemical(s) that make the flavor have a higher concentration in oak pulp.

It's something I read somewhere a long time back. And it's one of the reasons why they use Oak for a number of purposes in things like whisky/burbon (they use it for filtering the whisky, as well as the flavor it imparts), wine, and beer. Like I said, it's usually charred first to sanitize the wood.

rbw57
Wednesday, December 6, 2006 8:14:00 AM
Do not use Aromatic Cedar used to line closets and such, wrong kind and will ruin your sticks, use only Spanish Cedar!

RW