esong47
Saturday, December 2, 2006 9:31:00 AM
A few weeks ago, I got a five-pack of the IT Ltd. Reserve Bear after reading some decent reviews. I smoked one and found it ho-hum. I let them rest a while and tried smoking the second today, and found it unpleasantly bitter. I didn't even get halfway through the cigar.

My question: did I probably just experience one bad cigar, or could it be that my RH is too high? I have nothing but a little desktop humidor, and the hygrometer (which I salt tested a while back) reads 70%. I know that a lot of people here prefer a lower RH but honestly, I don't even know how I could adjust my RH since all I have is one of those little cheapo round black humdifying elements.

Would appreciate any advice--certainly want to get my storage options right before getting more (and more expensive) cigars.

Slimboli
Saturday, December 2, 2006 9:39:00 AM
I doubt humidity had anything to do with it ...

... you just didn't like it. Tastes are very subjective, and one man's treasure is another man's trash.

Move on and try different cigars ... there are so many dfferrent lines and vitola out there, you are sure find something that does it for you.

Dr Pepperhill
Saturday, December 2, 2006 11:11:00 AM
A way that I classify cigar flavor is thus:

1. mild

2. strong

3. tannic

4. spicy/floral

Most of the dog rockets are too tannic. They're bitter & taste like crap.

I don't like mild cigars, why not just have a cigarette if you want mild?

I like strong flavor.

A nice, natural spicey or floral flavor are often traits of super premium cigars.

In conclusion, a strong cigar, with little tannic flavor, and some interesting spicey or floral undertomes, typifies your most sought after smokes, and the price is usually reflective of that.

These are just guidelines. All cigars will have some tannic residue, and not all strong cigars, tannins or no, taste good.

Most cigars are dog rockets, with very few being the creme de la creme. Most dog rockets are (not including the infused or flavored ones) are either too mild or too tannic.

Everybody has different tastes, these are just some of my observations & simplifications.

cgbgjr
Saturday, December 2, 2006 1:11:00 PM
My experience is that you should never give up on a five pack too early. A classic case is the old Diesel. This was a true dog rocket off the truck--harsh and unsmokeable. Now, two years later, I am kicking myself for not buying more. They have mellowed into a wonderful smoke.

I have had the same happen with the 5 Vegas classic. These seem tasteless off the truck and have lots of flavor when they age.

Some of these guys just need some time.

mingkou
Saturday, December 2, 2006 3:57:00 PM
You might just have an unexperienced palate that is inevitable for new cigar smokers. When I first started smoking cigars I was all over the place on what I thought was good. A year later I could easily taste test the difference between every type of wrapper and to an extent, distinguish where the tobacco was grown. Don't go too overboard on keeping cigars a certain RH and such; just get some beads for $20 and have patience. If you don't taste traces of caramel and vanilla, citrus, passion fruit, etc., don't worry about it...most of the people who claim to do so are b.s.
pacman357
Saturday, December 2, 2006 4:38:00 PM
I think the IT Ltd. Reserve is one of the mildest sticks RP puts out. OK when I'm in the mood, just not a flavor bomb. Never had one that was bitter, however.

Glad to hear that about the diesels. I have most of a box collecting age.

esong47
Saturday, December 2, 2006 9:29:00 PM
I'm glad to report that I had a CAO Brazilia later in the day, and it was absolutely fantastic. No longer worried about the RH in my humidor!
jackconrad
Saturday, December 2, 2006 9:34:00 PM
I've had them and they were ok in other sizes. For some reason that size had way less flavor.
jackconrad
Saturday, December 2, 2006 9:35:00 PM
BTW , Diesels with a year or more age are a fantastic smoke.