Slowburning
Thursday, January 4, 2007 9:56:00 AM
What is the new standard that determines the strength/body (mild, medium, or full) of a cigar?

The old standard was determined by country of origin.

For example:

Jamaica, the Dominican Republic, the US produce Mild strength/body cigars;

Mexico, Honduras, Nicaragua produce Medium strength/body cigars; and

Honduras, Nicaragua and Cuba produce Full strength/body cigars.

It seems like the old standard no longer apply these days.

Kattmanntoo
Thursday, January 4, 2007 10:02:00 AM
I am beginning to think it is becoming a subjective issue, if you read certain magazines ( your choice there's only 3) it is all over the board. I am more likely to believe somebody on the forum than anything else. So I guess in a round-a-bout way I'm saying there seemingly no standard.
315press
Thursday, January 4, 2007 10:02:00 AM
Probably because there are less puros than non-puros.

While i would say that a puros from the DR would probably be mild and a puros from nicaruagua would be strong,

cigars coming out of nicaragua that are not puros, well who knows.

and of course the amount or lack of ligero will always affect body.

SteveR@CigarBid
Thursday, January 4, 2007 10:30:00 AM
The reason why such a standard could not exist is, the new strains of tobaccos being grown, the use of higher / lower primings from the same tobacco plant, the blending of various tobaccos from various countries, etc.

New strains of tobacco are being discovered quite frequently. New Cuban-seed Dominican tobaccos, for example. These Dominican leaves can be much stronger and much more flavorful than the standard Dominican leaf grown in the Cibao Valley.

Also, primings make a huge difference. Take any Honduran tobacco plant and consider its leaves. Those at the bottom (lower primings) receive the least amount of sunshine and are the first to be picked. Because of this, these tobaccos contain less nutrients, are thinner in nature and contain less oils and natural flavors. Now, move up the plant to the highest primings (5th or 6th). These are your 'corona' leaves, which remain on the plant until the end, and receive the most sunlight. This results in a thicker, oilier, more flavorful leaf. Using these leaves, which you may know as ligero, will result in a stronger smoke. Standard Dominican tobaccos may be milder than standard Honduran or Nicaraguan tobaccos, but the country's ligero does pack a punch...so not every Dominican puro will be mild in nature.

Blending is getting very creative. Dominican cigars now contain Nicaraguan, Honduran, Brazilian, Corojo, Cameroon, Mexican, etc tobaccos. This breaks all 'rules' when it comes to Dominican cigars being mild, since it's not just the Dominican at play.

What sets the standard you ask? Your palate. If it's mild to you, it's a mild-bodied cigar (to you). But, if somebody else finds it full-bodied, then it's a full-bodied cigar (to them).

How do manufacturers classify their cigars? By considering the tobaccos used and listening to their palates.

rx2010
Thursday, January 4, 2007 11:14:00 AM
aren't (one of) the only DR puros the Opus X?

which is generally considered rather full?

SteveR@CigarBid
Thursday, January 4, 2007 11:38:00 AM
Pueblo Dominicano Series II is a Dominican Puro. Medium-bodied.

Litto Gomez Diez is a Dominican Puro. Very full-bodied.

There are some others, as well.

jpotts
Thursday, January 4, 2007 12:01:00 PM
I propose a new standard. If after a churchill-size stick:

you're lying face-forward on the ground in a pool of your own vomit, and can't remember your name then they're classified as "full strength",

you want to take a nap, then they're "medium strenght",

you've got the munchies afterwards (or not), they're mild.

Can I get someone to second me on this?

bsevern
Thursday, January 4, 2007 12:49:00 PM
I would suggest that if you get the munchies after smoking, you're not smoking cigars, otherwise I agree.
ommegang
Thursday, January 4, 2007 1:55:00 PM
I don't know about face down and vomiting but, it would be nice if strength and body were stated on c-bid. Then again, it's all subjective. Personally, I consider the Antono Gran to be the standard for strength. Personally, I buy one at the local or a five pack from say, c-bid and go from there. I loaded up on boxes a few years back in anticipation of going away for a few years and came back to find my tastes changed dramatically and thus unloaded a lot of premium 3 year aged smokes just because they weren't strong enough to make my nose tingle. I'm just glad that the market is leaning toward the stronger smokes at present.