suntravler
Monday, January 29, 2007 8:52:00 PM
Gurkha Legend Aniversario Perfecto 12 Cigars Special ended tonight ( well now It was last night).

http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/lot.cfm?lotID=419587 

I have read a lot of the post about auto-bid. Saw Steve's explanation's as to how & why the program works like it does. If you auto-bid your bid moves up to guarantee you win -vs- no auto-bid and you take the risk of being out bid, but you could pay less if the price and # of bids stay down. The time you placed the bid ( earlier or later ) in the auction does not matter.

It still don't make sense!

Take a look at bidders 7 to 16 ... all but 2 bids were for 2 lots and placed on 1-24 between 9:27am & 10:32am. Price $55.99

Now look at bidder #95, used auto-bid & bid on 2 lots same day at 10:02am. Price $52.99 .... others that bid on 1 around same time at $52.99 all auto-bid. Very confusing!

Not worried about the $3, just like to know the rules of the game I am playing in. Love this site, but I cant make consistent sense of Auto-bid, other than I won. That's a good thing!

heynow5151
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 3:19:00 AM
Look at bids 1 and 2. You can start an auto bid higher than the asking price at the time like 1 and 2. I am not sure why people do this but it happens alot...Even CBid will let you pay more than you need to........
suntravler
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 4:05:00 AM
any explanation on this? #95 used auto-bid for 2 lots got for $52.99 .... all other 2 lot auto-bibs at same time went to $55.99.

No rhyme or reason to the method, that I see!

suntravler
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 4:06:00 AM
again sorry for the double post. I quit smoking to much something!
suntravler
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 7:50:00 AM
^ any answers ... thoughts?

or this is dead horse that's already been beaten!

So avoid at all cost!

Czechmate0
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 8:18:00 AM
Yes this has been beaten to death along with anyone who questions it. You and many others may disagree (including myself)with how they administer the bidding process in regard to the autobids. Basically you are paying a premium for using the autobid feature.

They have never answered the question as to why the bid amounts go up and down either. Never did understand how that could be part of the process. But what can you do. They are not changing the system so either accept it or don't use the autobid feature. According to them everything works as it is supposed to.

So if I were you I would stop beating my head against the wall and forget about it because you will get nowhere.

J.Redleg
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 8:25:00 AM
Beating a dead horse...
suntravler
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 9:26:00 AM
I don't mind paying a premium for auto-bid if all the bids work the same for everyone. In this example same auto-bid around same time ( with in 10min of each other) some went up, some some didn't. How do you pick which ones move? Flip a coin... you 6 up... you 6 down. Pick a straw ... I would take the lower.

Shot dead horse in the head... kicked it to!

Czechmate0
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 9:52:00 AM
I know it doesn't make it right, but you will get nowhere. So like I said, either except it or don't use the autobid, especially on the large lot specials.
jackconrad
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 9:56:00 AM
Cello on
joshuwaliu
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 12:47:00 PM
Is there something I'm missing? Seems like a simple algorithm to me. You put in starting bid and max autobid, then the listing takes the bids and then orders them from highest current bid at the top to lowest bid at the bottom, then within each price it sorts by date from oldest at top and newest at the bottom. Then when some new bid somes along, it bumps off whoever is at the bottom of the list, unless that bottom bid has autobid on, in which case the auto-bid is incremented and placed in the correct place on the list.

Thus higher bids have higher priority, and then earlier bids have higher priority. I think the only way your bid doesn't fit the pattern is if you don't put in the lowest acceptable bid, and manually bid at a higher price, and set autobid even higher.

Something I'm missing?

Czechmate0
Tuesday, January 30, 2007 5:34:00 PM
No it does not work exactly that way. This subject has been beat to death. If you use autobid, even if you bid earlier than someone not using the autobid your bid will get bumped with all the autobids once the lower price is exceeded, regardless if you bid earlier. Different than other auction sites but that is how they administer it here.