Andy,
I too would recommend just going around to different shops and sitting down and playing several different guitars. Each one will give you a different experience. Kind of like a woman. You know when you have the right one in your hands. Usually a local shop can give you a pretty good deal.
I am looking at a Les Paul electric guitar for my son that sounds better than any for the price range of 900.00. The sound is much better than the 2 to 4 thousand dollar ones. I found the exact same one on www.musciansfriend.com for less than 600.00. My family always favored the Gibson brand above the rest.
Martin is his choice for acoustic, but he wants an electric acoustic. Right now he plays an Ibanez and it sounds okay. I really like the sound of the Washburn guitars.
www.musiciansfriend.com has some really good deals sometimes and before we spent the money on any guitar I would go there and compare the price the local shop can give you with what they offer. They also have free shipping with all guitars over 99 bucks.
http://www.musiciansfriend.com/home/navigation?d=tp&q=cutaway+guitar&r=&src=00630
The above link is for cutaway acoustic guitars.
Also, in your local shops you can find consignment guitars that a local person has. Sometimes those are a pretty good deal.
It's all in what makes you happy. The one sound that would make me happy doesn't actually agree with another person.
I have musician friends that have bought from the link above and was very happy with the company. But again, each person has different choices and different opinions.
Good Luck,
Mrs. Hog