fatty
  • fatty
  • Rookie Topic Starter
Tuesday, February 20, 2007 4:52:00 PM
what do you do with that dog stick you light up an it does nothing for you
ARN
  • ARN
  • Herf-A-Holic
Tuesday, February 20, 2007 4:54:00 PM
Give it back to nature! The lawn loves them too...
hombre
Tuesday, February 20, 2007 4:55:00 PM
Cigars aren't like sex. Even bad sex is good. A bad cigar isn't worth the time.

I have no problem with tossing a bad one and getting another one I will enjoy. Quiet moments to smoke are few and far between for some of us with kids to waste time on something we wont enjoy.

Trash it after about 1.5 inches if it does not do it for you.

heynow5151
Tuesday, February 20, 2007 6:28:00 PM
The way a smoke evolves I smoke it all and decide if I will have another one any time soon. After two I decide if I will ever smoke them again. Some smoke with some age are all together different so give them a shot before giving them away. By no means ever through them away. Some body out there will like them. Even hang on to them to give to someone who doesn't smoke unless you give them one...ha ha ha
jackconrad
Tuesday, February 20, 2007 6:40:00 PM
pitch
ScottHar
Tuesday, February 20, 2007 7:11:00 PM
^Hombre (#3) said it -- I tossed two sticks this past weekend when they just weren't doin' it for me (my toddler naps for about 90 minutes and I'm going to ENJOY those mini-vacations on the patio outside his room).

ScottHar

samholmes
Tuesday, February 20, 2007 7:26:00 PM
But don't bail on a certain smoke just because you didn't enjoy it once. Many things can effect how a cigar tastes. Aging, storage, what you have eaten or drank, the mood your in can make a good cigar taste like a dog rocket. If you light a smoke and it tastes like a turd, pitch it and try something else. Come back to that smoke another time and if you don't like it then, you have given it a fair chance.

Some time ago a friend gave me a couple of Punch Gran Puros. I had heard good things about it, so one the way home from work I light one up. After about an inch, I couldn't stand it anymore and pitched it. Thought it was on the level of a Duque. This weekend I found the other one and decided to try again. Found it was an excellent smoke.

sw48362
Tuesday, February 20, 2007 7:49:00 PM
toss it! ...unless you are lacking cigars...Sometimes just not my cup of tea, or one in the batch got screwed up somehow. Toss it!
pgje51
Wednesday, February 21, 2007 5:42:00 AM

I have two dwarf citrus trees in large pots that have never turned away

from an offering. Totally situational as to how long I'll give a stick before tossing it to them.

biga1973
Wednesday, February 21, 2007 6:29:00 AM
Never - EVER smoke a bad cigar. That is MAN LAW.
trabin
Wednesday, February 21, 2007 6:32:00 AM
The worst is trying to smoke a cigar that won't draw. In the end you end up with a cramped jaw, frustrated, and usually not enough time to smoke another.
daveincincy
Wednesday, February 21, 2007 6:46:00 AM
Author: trabin Date: 02/21/2007 11:32 AM Reply

The worst is trying to smoke a cigar that won't draw. In the end you end up with a cramped jaw, frustrated, and usually not enough time to smoke another.

=====================================================

I ran into this with a Cohiba. Since it was the only one I had, and I paid retail for it, I wasn't about to toss it. I'd give Cohibas another shot as this was an isolated incident, but man did my face hurt in the end....good stuff.

CROS
Wednesday, February 21, 2007 10:56:00 AM
Re # 7 - what do you do if the stick you tossed is one that was gifted to you. I had this situation happen last week and again last night. They were both very nice sticks that I had been wanting to try for awhile. One ended up plugged and one ended up tasting like dirt. I know they are good because I have heard other BOTL's say they enjoy them. I don't want to write them off, but at the same time, it is tainted in my mind for at least the next little while. The next time I'm at the B & M wanting a nice stick, I will go with just about everything in there over one that I've already had a bad experience with. Forget about me getting a five pack either. Like it was said, the times for a cigar are too few and far between for me to feel like gambling with those brands... at least for a while.

Sorry if this is considered a threadjack. I got a little long winded once I got started.

pacman357
Wednesday, February 21, 2007 11:32:00 AM
"Life is too short to be sucking on bad cigars."

--Sigmund Freud

Thunder.Gerbil
Wednesday, February 21, 2007 11:41:00 AM
Somewhere I read a FAQ that contained a question like:

"At what point do you stop smoking a cigar? Half-way? At the band? The nub?"

The answer (which I believe was from Steve Saka) went something like this:

"At the point which you stop enjoying it."

I'm good with that theory, even if it means putting it down once and for all after a mere 1/2"-3/4".

If it's a dog-rocket, I just did myself a favor. If it's an uber-premium that isn't burning right, I did myself a BIGGER favor.