Gonz@CigarBid
Monday, May 8, 2000 9:09:00 AM
I'm about to make some changes to the forum (prompted by aberdeen's email to us about categories) and wanted to present the changes before I do so. I propose the following simple fixes to change things up a little:

1. remove the Merchandise and Other Stuff boards since there is very little play there anyway

2. add a Trades board, so those of you with a trade going can communicate off of the main Cigar board.

Any thoughts or other suggestions.

gonz

webmaster

mikeconley
Monday, May 8, 2000 12:09:00 PM
Is it possible for the date of the topic to reflect the date of the most recent posting inthat thread versus the initial posting date? sometimes it gets hard to remember how many repsponses there were to each thread so tyat I know whether someone else has written to one or not.
aberdeen
Monday, May 8, 2000 4:26:00 PM
okay, I thought for a minute you were going to bring up my past again! But at least my email went to some good. I would suggest not being able to create new threads at every whim, like I seem to do often. But have four or five main subjects headings, then we can check each subect heading each day for new post, so instead of new threads we just continously keep adding to the main five subjects or so. That way to make the person above happy, when we go to each subject, we see the most recent post first. Now within each subject heading we can leave a subject within it, if that makes sense. And we can respond to that specific subject. That will clear up all the clutter that is forming, into nice tidy packages. I mean you can still have a merchandise subject area, as we do discuss humidors etc., but just have one subject for merchandise, we can click on that and see all the topics discussed on cigar related products, again from the most recent first. Does this make sense at all? You might have a section for the cigar lifestyle, and a subject specifically to talk about cigar brands. You could probably scan all these threads over the last month or two and find four or five major themes. You could even, dare I say it, have a political board, and we can bash the tobacco nazis for a change.
soothesayer
Monday, May 8, 2000 7:41:00 PM
I think that a cigar trade board is an excellent idea.It gives those of us who are not involved in an active circulating trade group an opportunity to meet others,gain confidences,and find cigars that we otherwise have not tried.Most of all,we can trade for the exact cigars that we want...not those contained in a mystery box.
Gonz@CigarBid
Tuesday, May 9, 2000 8:18:00 AM
It sounds like you're basically asking for a larger selection of categories than the three we have now. As new guys come on board, most will just post to the first category they see, which has been the cigar board. I do like the idea of more categories, but selecting the categories might get tough. How do you feel about selecting:

- Cigar Stuff

- Cigar Trade

- Political Venue

- any others???

I could also have an initial page that only lists the categories and not the threads in each category if that would help. Then, a user would select a category and see all the threads in the category.

gonz

Gonz@CigarBid
Tuesday, May 9, 2000 11:08:00 AM
Good suggestion. It's done. The date shown on the forum homepage is now the date of the last update to the thread. However, the newest threads are still at the top.
robnsue
Tuesday, May 9, 2000 12:17:00 PM
Hard to believe somebody is bitchin' about a mystery box trade....especially when they don't belong to either active trade group on cigarbid. There is a so much more going on then "mystery box" between these groups. There is an education and a limited forum to discuss our preferences and voice our questions to people who have established a trustworthiness by provong they are as good as their word. There has been 2 free cigars, discounted goods, and a partnership of splitting boxes of "special" cigars. However, It is to bad that some people such as soothsayer would rather "bad mouth" than try to share their knowlegde and friendship in a trade group. Thanks again to my new friends..EVG_ACA_BB,JOECAT16,MICK1,FBCoachOreed,HokieBama,and Rookie.
soothesayer
Tuesday, May 9, 2000 1:46:00 PM
It sounds like you are a bit touchy about this subject-I guess I struck a nerve.I would hardly call my one statement bitching or bad mouthing either.I want to make clear that a trading board would open up opportunities for everyone as well as lines of comunication.I am sorry that you feel that this idea is too anti-establishment.
aberdeen
Tuesday, May 9, 2000 5:02:00 PM
not sure what you mean with that message. But what I meant is when someone clicks to go to the forum, they will not see this huge list of threads, but four categories, then click on a category of their choosing to view what was written in it, and leave their subject in the subject area in a post, like above, "recent date". Then anyone can specifically reply to that subject.
fbcoacho
Wednesday, May 10, 2000 6:52:00 AM
as thr "RingLeader" of the Elite 8 Swap Club, i would like to offer my comments. First off, I too would like to see a Trade Board Post Group. This would free up this petty bull**** going on.Second,the so-called"mystery box" this Group of 8 has agreed that we all enjoy cigars and would like to try other brands that we've seen in shops but weren't sure bout spending the cash. With OUR setup the chance is there howeverthe cost factor is minimal,also the "mystery box" has a complete critique of all additions that are put in so that the MEMBERS can read how OTHER MEMBERS describe their thoughts on that particular smoke.Lastly, within this Group of 8 i believe that we have started a solid friendship and possible network opportunities, the Group has members in OHIO,CALF,IOWA,ILLINOIS,MASS, and we keep in contact daily with various topics(sports,cigars,new cigar stores,etc). if any others who frequent this page would like help in starting a group on their own i would be glad to give you Our procedures they're not that demanding but it does take some time.

As for Gonzo the Webmaster,thank you for all that you have done for this forum..... fbcoacho(randy)

soothesayer
Wednesday, May 10, 2000 3:06:00 PM
Thankyou for supporting the trade board post group idea.I want to further add that my previous statement was in no way designed to discredit your group(s) or for that matter any of its members."Mystery box" was only an offhand label not to be confused with an insult.I am sorry if it was construed as the latter.My only goal is too see that a trading board goes up on this site because not all of us has the opportunity,locality, or (not to sound like Lars) "the wherewithal" to join a trading group.
fbcoacho
Wednesday, May 10, 2000 3:47:00 PM
no offense taken. randy(coach)
Slimboli
Saturday, February 24, 2007 1:11:00 PM
For those interested on how we got the different boards ...
sw48362
Saturday, February 24, 2007 3:40:00 PM
It was interesting sifting through the early post of 2k.

plinytheelder
Saturday, February 24, 2007 6:15:00 PM
Too bad that in 7 years, they haven't added an

Edit Button