CBOB
18 years ago
I've always been a fan of the Weber charcoal grill, but I have wondered about the Big Green Egg. Anyone ever use it?

http://www.biggreenegg.com/ 

diverbelow72
18 years ago
Come on Andy, you know you want a Weber. I got a Smokey Jr, it's like a 10-12 inch and then I have an 18" One Touch? Love them both. I actually found the 18" in the trash room of my apartment building, looks like it was used once, no more than twice. Now if I could have only found the WSm here I would have been set.
Diver
Thunder.Gerbil
18 years ago
^^^
Someone figured out what is probably the only way to improve on the weber design and the Big Green Egg is the result.

Their only real downside is the astronomical cost.
pacman357
18 years ago
#18 I did not know that. That is weird, wild stuff. The materials on the one I have are pretty damned heavy, too. In fact, we had several bad windstorms late last year and early this year (quite a few milder ones, too, but some where we lost power for 1-4 days). I was stunned one day when we had wind strong enough to blow that BBQ over. I'd have figured it would take a hurricane.

#20 Andy, it looks like that is the smart grill to get. Apparently you can surf the internet and type on it.
BOBRQ
18 years ago
I have the Primo Grill Large oval, similar to the Big Green Egg. I have a couple of Weber 22" and a smoker . The Primo is unbelievable and I have not used anything else since! It is a bit pricey but you will never need another grill or smoker again
CBOB
18 years ago
Article on the Egg --

Put all your grilling in one Big Green Egg
By Jonathan Levitt, Globe Correspondent
May 23, 2007

Americans tend to splurge on big powerful things: 400 horsepower pickups for getting around; 15,000 BTU burners for the kitchen; and for the backyard, the Big Green Egg.

Ovate in shape, and British racing green in color, the egg is an enameled ceramic grill/oven/smoker that is heavy (the large model weighs 140 pounds) and expensive (it costs about $900). Fueled by hardwood charcoal, the egg can slow- cook a beef brisket for 18 hours, sear rib - eye steaks over hot fruit wood flames, or blaze up to 750 degrees to bake thin-crust pizza in two minutes. Devotees of the grill -- it has a cult following -- refer to themselves as Eggers or Eggheads. They share cooking tips in online chat rooms and gather for the annual EggFest in Waldorf, Md.

The Big Green Egg factory opened in Atlanta in 1974. Now the grills are made in Mexico, the design loosely based on the ancient Japanese Kamado cookers. Ceramic walls retain and radiate heat. "It cooks like an oven, but then you have the smoky flavor, too," says Frank Monzione, a 64-year-old salesman at Yankee Fireplace & Grill City in Middleton. Of course Monzione has a large Big Green Egg on his back patio in Revere. "In the summer I cook on my egg just about every day," he says. "I even roasted my first turkey out there." The eggs come in several sizes, ranging from the "mini" at $300 (large enough for three or four hamburgers) to the extra-large at $900, and there are a variety of accessories, including wood stand s or "nest s," some with shelves.

At Kirley Masonry Supply in Mansfield, owners Jefferson and Eric Strom, who are brothers, sell a few Big Green Eggs a day in the summer. "Once people figure out what it's all about they become fanatical about it," says Jefferson. Both agree that while there are many kamado-style cookers on the market -- even Viking came out with a stainless steel "Charcoal Ceramic Cooking Capsule," recently -- none have the broad appeal of the Big Green Egg.

Monzione says that a lot of his customers have high-end stainless steel outdoor kitchens with high BTU gas grills. But they can't provide what the Big Green Egg can: the taste of food cooked over wood. "They come in looking for charcoal cookers because they want that wood flavor."

That wood flavor is essential to good barbecue. Chris Hart, a 38-year-old competitive barbecue champion and software designer from Hopkinton, cooks on a Big Green Egg with his pit crew. He won his first egg at last year's Jack Daniel's World Championship Invitational Barbecue contest in Tennessee. The iQue team was one of six squads chosen at random to cook on the eggs in an Iron-Chef-style contest. Cornish game hens were the mystery ingredient. Team iQue roasted the bacon-wrapped breasts, barbecued the legs, and made a white chocolate chip cake with bananas Foster for dessert.

"Cooking on the egg was like going from driving a normal car to driving a Ferrari," says Hart. "Right away we bought another egg for the team and commissioned a hand-carved wooden handle with the iQue logo. We've been cooking on it ever since."

Hart keeps the egg he won on his back porch. "It's my go-to grill," he says. "Even my wife is pleased. She was sick of all my greasy iron barbecue rigs. But she likes the look of the egg."

dkeage
18 years ago
RE: 21, see post #14, I've had a Big Green Egg for 14 years now, and it Rocks!! I wouldn't have anything else, and they last forever, as long as you don't crack em!
pacman357
18 years ago
"I've had a Big Green Egg for 14 years now"

You really should see a doctor about that.
Thunder.Gerbil
18 years ago
^^^
Or get some ham.
andytv
  • andytv
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
18 years ago
eggs are awesome.........but very expensive.

dkeage is a grill master and he has the shit to prove it.
dkeage
18 years ago
^ Thanks andy, my proctologist would agree.......

Yes, they are pretty pricey..........but it's one of the best buys we've made since we got married.......We got a gas grill as a wedding gift that crapped out in 2 years....

Lump charcoal, and a chimney starter is the way the Settlers first grilled!!!!!!!


Homebrew
18 years ago
I have an ancient weber. Almost as old as I am. The legs are gone, and it rests, on stacked cinderblocks now. It still is the best grill I have ever owned. You can't go wrong, with a weber.

Dave (A.K.A. Homebrew)
StogeeBoy
18 years ago
I got a Char-Griller Smokin Pro at home depot for $159...work great as a smoker and as a grill. I use the extra flame box to start the wood...then I use a garden spade to transfer over to the big side...a little work but never gets too hot and smokes perfectly. It sure take a lot of coal for grilling though...will last literally 4-5 hours if you fill it half way
jjohnson28
andytv
  • andytv
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
18 years ago
OK....bought the Weber Gold.

I was intrigued by the version with the table top and the gas assist for lighting, but it was too costly, the table ain't really big enough, and I have a table outside anyway.

Stogee...........I have one like yours too. I like it, but you are right......it really hammers the fuel. I'm gonna donate mine to my neighbor once I get my outdoor kitchen set up and tweaked.
jjohnson28
18 years ago
The Weber Gold Rocks, and the ash catcher is well worth the extra $50 or so dollars IMHO. I have one as well and while not totally necessary these charcoal rails are a nice accessory.

Charcoal rails;

http://www.amazon.com/Weber-3901-Charcoal-Rails/dp/B00004RAM8 

I prefer these to the baskets myself.

Baskets;

http://www.amazon.com/Weber-9600Char-Basket-Charcoal-Fuel-Holders/dp/B0000CBIL1/ref=pd_bbs_5/002-9101131-5062427?ie=UTF8&s=home-garden&qid=1187354158&sr=8-5 


JJ
andytv
  • andytv
  • Herf-A-Holic Topic Starter
18 years ago
just an update.........my neighbor brags up his $600 gasser quite often......that was UNTIL I wheeled this Weber over to do some chicken for a Steeler game.

I wheeled it back but noticed a few days later it was gone.

He had "borrowed" it.

He has borrowed it about a dozen times since.

What a GREAT grill........sure it "grills" fine, but it really excels as a charcoal oven for roasting, etc.

dkeage
18 years ago
Gene363
18 years ago
I wore out two Webbers over the years. They are good for grilling, but I really liked smoking roasts and turkeys. When we lived in California, we used live oak bark for smoke. It really imparts a tangy flavor and nice color to the meat.

I used to cook outside a lot but my wife wanted the convenience of gas grill. We got a nice Webber gas grill, but it is NOT as a good as charcoal, perhaps slightly better than pan-frying. I rarely use it.

CD44
18 years ago
I like my my Brinkmann Smoke-N-Pit dual use horizontal offset fire box smoker and charcoal grill. If are looking for just a grill then I think the Webers are hard to beat.
Users browsing this topic