"Whoever solves this enigma wrapped inside a mystery, gets my vote for Professor CBID."
I guess you can call me Prof. CBid, LOL. I solved the puzzle last night in a few minutes. The puzzle was posted here:
http://www.cigarbid.com/auction/forum/forum.cfm?action=list&forumID=6&messageDisplay=0000000123739
All of the posts in the various threads were setting up a list of equivalent characters to code or decode a message (for example 25=z). Basically, he gave us his alphabet in numeric and symbolic characters in all of those posts and then left a coded message in the final contest post and asked for us to decode the message to identify a cigar.
The decoded message was an internet address to a CBid auction lot for a Camacho Liberty 2007 11/18.
Regards,
-JT