Padron #3000 or #5000, depending on your taste in ring gauge and maduro or natural.
Padron 1926 #1. Best non-Cuban I've smoked.
Opus X Double Corona. Separates the men from the boys, cigarically speaking.
Padron Magnum Maduro. Make the time to smoke this baton.
Any Padron 1964 Maduro. I'm partial to the larger sizes.
Does anyone other than Padron and Fuente make non-Cuban cigars? LOL! You'd never know it from my non-Cuban humidor.
John