For anyone that has not seen this yet.

In no particular order:

La Gloria Cubana
Hoyo de Monterrey
Bucanero
Indian Tabac
ISOM Romeo y Julieta
Pimp Sticks

five of my favorites

1. Toraño Signature
2. Padron 5000 Maduro
3. CAO Brazilia Gol!
4. Gurkha Regent Torpedo
5. Bucanero Peg leg

There ya go!

Mag

It was hard to pick the top five, but I think these are
right up there.

Flor de Filipinas
Don Escobar
Red Label
Bad Frog
Hugo Cassar

PAM
Padron Maduro
CAO Maduro
Gurkha Master Select
Cuesta Ray Centenario Natural

1. Ashton VSG
2. Camacho Corojo
3. DC Maximus
4. Gurkha
5. AF Hemingway line


Rick

I'm a big fan of the the Fuente/Newman family of cigars
Fuente Hemingway (short story, WOA)maduros preferred over naturals
Ashton VSG
Diamond Crown (including the new Maximus)
Fuente Anejo
CAO Brazilia (just to mix it up a little)

Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Belicoso (life is so short)
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Classics natural (haven't found any maduros)
Ashton VSG Sorcerer
Arturo Fuente Chateau Fuente sun-grown and maduro
Henry Clay

Bucanero (Z,full sail, salsa)
AF (Hemingways,Don Carlos, 858 SG)
Padron (PAM, 3000 maddie)
La Aurora 1903
Carlos Torano (Ex 1959 gold, silver)
LFD Double Ligero/chisel

Padron #3000 or #5000, depending on your taste in ring gauge and maduro or natural.

Padron 1926 #1. Best non-Cuban I've smoked.

Opus X Double Corona. Separates the men from the boys, cigarically speaking.

Padron Magnum Maduro. Make the time to smoke this baton.

Any Padron 1964 Maduro. I'm partial to the larger sizes.

Does anyone other than Padron and Fuente make non-Cuban cigars? LOL! You'd never know it from my non-Cuban humidor.

John

In no particular order:

Cusano Corojo
HDM Excalibur 1066
Torano Signature & Reserva Selecta
Acid Def Sea
Trilogy (all 3 lines)

Those are my "go-to" sticks, but if money were not object, the list would be a bit different.

My current favorite everyday smokes include:

CAO (Black Label)
Cusano (Corojo)
La Excepcion (III & IV)
Trilogy (Corojo and Cammy)
Maria Mancini (Magic Mountain)

All usually avalible for between $1 and $3 per stick.

AF Short Story
Partagas Black Pyramide
Padron 3000
Punch Double Corona
Ashton Corona

Really want to try an Ashton VSG and an Opus X. Probably wait until Christmas to get one of each.

It is hard to single 5 cigars out. Singling out 5 brands is difficult. Tim, here are my everydays...life is too short to not smoke your favorites for everydays.

Montecristo No.2 (ISOM or not)
Hoyo De Monterrey limited ed. Excalibur
Perdomo 2 Torfecto is favorite of line
CAO many kinds
Opus X triple belicoso

Like I said and many before me, too many to choose from out there to only have five in your rotation and humi's

RJ

Camacho Corojo Figurado
Padron Anniv. 1964 Exclusivo Mad
Torano Exodus 1959 Double Corona
Hoyo Excalibur #1 Mad
C.A.O. Anniv. Cameroon Toro

AF Hemingways
Ashton Aged Maduros
PAMs
Diamond Crown
AF Don Carlos
any of the CAOs except the Gold

In no particular order whatsoever:

~Hoyo De Monterrey Dark Sumatra
~Belinda Black
~Bock Y Ca (Habana 2000 wrapper)
~Oliva "O" bold
~Perdomo^2 (exponente)

these are all basically low-to-mid priced sticks, but all are great "everyday" smokes. Just my 2 cents!

Bucanero Classic Maduro
Ashton VSG
Any Fuente sungrown
OpusX
CAO
Avo Maduro

KC

BTW - I didn't list any ISOM because I would NEVER break the law 😉

Again, in no order:

1. Hemingway Maduro
2. Anejo
3. PAM
4. Ashton Cabinet
5. AF Sungrowns

Few more days.