nwb
  • nwb
  • Aficionado Topic Starter
Wednesday, February 16, 2005 5:58:00 PM
I know you guys have probably done one of these before on this forum, but I have a couple of theories about cigars in general. Once I get enough posts, I'll let you know the theories; then I'll tally up the results and let you all know.

List your top 10 favorite lines of cigars (1 being your favorite). Only domestics please, and be honest.

Tell how long you have been smoking cigars.

example:

1) Padron Anniversary

2) Fuente Anejo

3) Ashton VSG

4) Padron XOOO

5) CAO Italia

Smoking for 3 years.

Thanks guys

nwb

WaldoAR15
Wednesday, February 16, 2005 6:13:00 PM

Something from Padron, Fuentes, or Partagas. In no order and no real favorite. I don't stray much from those three.

FOG, I don't know exactly how many years I've been smoking cigars 😉

18delta
Wednesday, February 16, 2005 6:49:00 PM
fuente 858 sungrown

ashton vsg belicoso #1

davidoff millenium blend lonsdale

fuente anejo 46 and other sizes

fuente hemi maddies

montecristo millenium blend tubos-churchill

fuente opus x

la aurora 100 anos

la aurora prefs

camacho liberty series

perdomo edicion de silvio

18delta
Wednesday, February 16, 2005 6:50:00 PM
oh yeah, been smoking for about five or so years
tpottiger
Wednesday, February 16, 2005 9:05:00 PM
Honestly, in no specific order, cause there ain't one...

COA Brazilia

Diablo

CAO Italia

AF Hemingway

Onyx Reserve

Partagus Black

Helix Maduro

Acid Natural Elixer 5-50

IT Fire

IT Maduro

Smoking on and off for about 7 years... (more active the last 3.)

There are quite a few more that are on my go to list, but these are probably my top ten.

lukin
Wednesday, February 16, 2005 9:25:00 PM
Without resorting to the database, and in no particular order.....

1. CAO Italia

2. CAO Brazilia

3. Torano 1916 Cameroon

4. Padron #3000

5. IT Super Fuerte Maduros

6. Bolivar Fuerte Cuban Corona

7. PAM 1964(i've only had one but it was awesome)

8. Vintage 1990 Toro by Rocky Patel

9. La Aroma de Cuba

10. Torano Signature

I have had a lot of cigars that were better than some of the ones that were listed here, but factoring in price, reliability, and experience, I would say that these are my top ten. I even hated putting the PAM 1964 but it was way too good. Noticeably absent from the list is Perdomo...which I used to think were awful, but lately have been making a comeback 🙂

Stickbow
Thursday, February 17, 2005 2:14:00 AM
I have been smoking for about five years.

In no real order.

CAO Brazilia

Padron maddie

Padron maddie 64

padron 26

Torano sigs.

Torano trib maddie

AVO #2 maddie

CAO Italia

JDN GC

LFD Cheisel

stic

andytv
Thursday, February 17, 2005 2:34:00 AM
Only been smoking 2.5 years, so my list changes each month, but for today's snapshot;

1) AF Don Carlos

2) PAN64

3) AF Hemingway

4) H. Upmann Reserve Cameroon

5) Camacho SLR

6) AF Chateau

7) Torano Dominican

8) IT ire

gvenlet
Thursday, February 17, 2005 2:50:00 AM
No Order

Punch Champion

Hoyo de monterrey 1066

Feunte 858

off and on cigar smoker 20+ years

JSD
  • JSD
  • Connoisseur
Thursday, February 17, 2005 4:25:00 AM
In no order;

Fuente Anejo

Fuente Don Carlos

CAO Brazilia

Excalibur by Hoyo (particularly the Prensado)

Joya de Nic Anos

Off and on for 10 years

BLISTER
Thursday, February 17, 2005 9:21:00 AM
In no particular order:

Bauza Pyramid

Fuente Cuban Belicoso SG

Torano Signature

Torano Reserva Selecta Torp

Torano Exodus 59 Torp

Padron #2000 0r #3000 maduro

Excalibur #3

CAO Anniv. Cameroon Belicoso

Onyx Reserve Mini Belicoso

Perdomo Reserve Cameroon X,V, or D

I really like the CAO Italia's but I haven't had enough to put them on the list.

Been smokin' for 15 years

Joe

bassdude
Thursday, February 17, 2005 9:33:00 AM
nwb - as you can see this will be hard to compile. I could not sit down and say oh yeah this one is my all time favorite. I can give a top 10.

Now on the Habano side I could definitely list my #1 but from there it evens out again.

bassdude
Thursday, February 17, 2005 9:49:00 AM
oh yeah, smoked purely machin made and store bought for over 15 years with the occasional hand rolled. Then found real cigars maybe 6 years ago and stopped what the 10 years brought me. so you can say 6 or 21
BeatDragon
Thursday, February 17, 2005 9:50:00 AM
In no particular order

Boli Fuerte (preferrably the Cuban Corona)

Boli SRO

CAO Brazilia

Partagas Black

Ashton VSG

HDM Selleccion Royale Maduro

HDM Maddies (all of um)

Excalibur Epicure (Hell any Excalibur Maddy)

HDM Estello Padron 75th Annniv Maduro

La Aurora Pref.

About 10 years

Bucephalus
Thursday, February 17, 2005 11:14:00 AM
Smoking cigars for 12 years...like large ring sizes and mimimum of 6.0 long.

(75% of te cigars I smoke these days are below)

Oliva "O", both Maduro and Natural

Ghurka, all the premium versions

Padron Anniversary series

La Gloria Cubana SerieR

Montecristo Whites

Rocky Patel '92 Torpedo

(Less expensive favorites)

Gispert

Maria Guerera

myash07
Thursday, February 17, 2005 1:57:00 PM
Sorry

They just don't make my favorite anymore..

:>p

Tazziedevil
Thursday, February 17, 2005 2:20:00 PM
first off....domestics for me include cubans, since I'm in Australia. So....in no particular order,

Helix maduro

Don Tomas special edition

Perdomo exponente

Montecristo Afrique

Cuban El Rey Del Mundo Dbl Corona

Honduran Punch Gran Cru

Belinda Black

Cupido

CAO L'anniversare

Hoyo De Monterrey Dark Sumatra

Been smoking for about 6 years.

briguy151
Thursday, February 17, 2005 5:17:00 PM
PAM

Opus x

Partagas Black

RyJ maddies

Gurkha Centurian X

CAO Italia

Torano 1959

AF Anejo

AF 858 maddie

CAO Crillo

Smokin cigars since september 04

"I gave up a bad habit for a better one" - Jack Nicholson

sleepymonky
Thursday, February 17, 2005 6:20:00 PM
well so much for gettin a good price on these anytime soon eh? is that how this works?
18delta
Thursday, February 17, 2005 6:37:00 PM
you must scour the land in search of good prices....