Without resorting to the database, and in no particular order.....
1. CAO Italia
2. CAO Brazilia
3. Torano 1916 Cameroon
4. Padron #3000
5. IT Super Fuerte Maduros
6. Bolivar Fuerte Cuban Corona
7. PAM 1964(i've only had one but it was awesome)
8. Vintage 1990 Toro by Rocky Patel
9. La Aroma de Cuba
10. Torano Signature
I have had a lot of cigars that were better than some of the ones that were listed here, but factoring in price, reliability, and experience, I would say that these are my top ten. I even hated putting the PAM 1964 but it was way too good. Noticeably absent from the list is Perdomo...which I used to think were awful, but lately have been making a comeback 🙂